A short argument on Platonic Space: variable-agency patterns that in-form physics, biology, computer science, and cognitive science

Published by

on

I have been thinking about the insufficiency of physicalism and its scientific and personal implications for somewhat over 40 years. But I’ve only started talking about them publicly in 2025, because I saw no point in adding to the Philosophy and New Age bookshelves – relevant ideas are ancient, and plenty of much smarter people have opined in this direction without moving the needle much on the mainstream paradigm. What’s different now however is that these ideas have become more strongly actionable. Not merely “testable”, but able to drive new research programs. Thus, it becomes important to lay out a conceptual foundation that is informed by the latest discoveries, and sketch a research program that this framework enables. It’s time, and I’ve now mentioned this in a number of talks.

There is currently a convergence of work in this direction from others as well. The machine learning (computer science) community is approaching it from one side. The cognitive science field has its own “anomalous” data on the linkage between mind and brain which suggest there may be foundational gaps in our understanding (see one review here). And of course, non-physicalist theories in philosophy abound. What I’m doing is taking an approach that I think is new in 3 ways: I’ve tried to

(1) anchor it in experiments in developmental/synthetic biology, and interface tightly with the diverse intelligence field,

(2) make a specific proposal for understanding causation and interactionism (the claim that the mind:brain relationship is the same as the math:physics relationship) that connects well to Platonist ideas in mathematics but extends them far outside of math, and

(3) broaden the usual dualistic framework, in ways that neither materialists nor organicists tend to like by arguing that the non-physical patterns that drive advanced cognition are drawn from the same space as those that drive minimal physical and computational systems. In other words, that there are no truly dumb machines and dead matter, nor any magical divide that makes us unique in being more than our formal models of algorithms and physics.

The long-form version of my current views can be see in this blog post and videos (this, and this briefer one). Also the preprint (although it’s now quite dated and is being revised and improved to a new version); much more is coming on this in the form of papers. Of course, there’s also our symposium which has many others’ excellent, related talks.

Here, I wanted to present the bones of the ideas in a tight way that attempts to make the logic clear and simple. There’s a lot of misunderstanding of the claims (for example, some people think that I’m going down this road only because of Xenobots etc.; that is not the case). It’s helpful to lay the sequential argument out step by step so everyone can see what it leans on, and perhaps decide which step (or which inference) they disagree with. The left column of the table is close to a philosophy/logic format of argument. The right column is some commentary on each one. Here goes:

Argument Commentary
There are facts which are not physical facts.These include truths of topology, the shape of specific fractal structures, the distribution of primes, the contents of your discrete math and computer science textbooks, the fact that complex numbers, octonions, quaternions all keep different promises, etc.    They cannot be found using the tools of physics, and knowing physics doesn’t help. Can you disband the math department and hope the physicists find them? No. Can they be changed by tweaking the universal constants at the time of the big bang? No.  If you agree that you can’t simply dissolve the math department, then that’s it – we have 2 distinct (but interacting) realms. Now we can do some science and understand how those relate, and how other disciplines come into it.
Let’s call these facts (for maximum generality) “patterns”:

These patterns are discovered, not created by us.

Therefore we can start thinking about the latent space from which specific ones are drawn.
I realize this is a huge debate in the philosophy of mathematics. What I find convincing is that you can start with something like set theory (define set membership and successors) and eventually end up with a very specific value of e, the natural logarithm. You don’t get to choose it, it’s forced on you by very minimal assumptions.
The fact that aliens that started with different assumptions would see a different subset of these facts is not problematic – they would simply have access to a different set of discovered patterns.
Others argue that these patterns don’t “pre-exist” in some sense but are generated by us. I’m not sure how much of the below would be affected by that; we’d still have to study the space of them, and answer the questions at the end.
These patterns are important for physics, biology, and computer science.Evolution exploits them as affordances it doesn’t need to pay for. For example, once you find a voltage-gated ion channel, you have a transistor which can make logic gates, and truth tables (and facts like the special nature of NAND) are yours for free, you don’t need to evolve them specifically. There are tons of such examples.
Also, we know when we paid the computational cost of evolving natural life forms – in the eons of selection against environments. But when was the computational cost of evolving Xenobots and Anthrobots (and all their cool new capabilities) paid? They’ve never existed, so there was never selection for these features. Where do the specific capabilities and properties of novel beings come from? What determines them? Saying they “emerged” at the time you were evolving frogs and humans just basically rips up the whole point of evolutionary theory (a tight predictive relationship between an organism’s features and a past history of selection in specific environments, which explains those features). No one predicted their new transcriptomes, the sound-response ability of Xenobots, the neural healing ability of Anthrobots, from the selection forces and frog/human environment. Waiting until they show up and then claiming emergence is sterile; we need to be able to predict them, which means, mapping the space.
These patterns are causal in physics, biology, and computer science because, a) if they were different, facts in the physical world would be different, and b) they serve as best explanations for why the physical world is the way it is.If you’re worried about interactionism (functionally causal physical:non-physical interactions), too bad – that ship had already sailed in the time of Pythagoras, who knew that non-physical truths control our world.

a) they are causal in Judea Pearl’s sense of counterfactual; for example, if the prime number distribution was otherwise, then the cicadas would come out at years other than 13 and 17. 

b) I think the best sense of causation, e.g., “A caused B”, is if A is the best (most enabling, insightful) explanation for why B, rather than C, happens. In this sense too, non-physical patterns are causal. Whatever your question – in cognitive science, biology, physics – just keep asking “but why?” and you will always end up in the math department. Why do the fermions do this or that? Because of a symmetry of some mathematical object. Why do the cicadas come out at certain years? Because of the distribution of primes.  And so on.
Therefore, physicalism is insufficient in an important way and we need to investigate this latent space of patterns.The above points imply that we have to take these non-physical patterns seriously in our explanations and in our engineering (in a sense, all engineering is partly reverse-engineering, as you’re trying to exploit the autonomous capabilities of your chosen substrate). They have consequences for what we investigate and build, and how.
Moving science forward requires us to not assume this space of patterns is random but rather is ordered, structured, and amenable to exploration.This is a metaphysical stance, and I can’t prove it, but I find the alternative terribly pessimistic. I choose positivity.
Same with “emergence” – it’s just not useful enough. First, it just means you got surprised (things that seem emergent to one observer, are obvious consequences to a smarter one). Second, it’s just too defeatist to say “there’s no understandable latent space from which surprising properties are drawn; these ‘regularities’ we observe in the world are just random and that’s that.” Third, we still have to say why one pattern “emerged” rather than another, and to whatever extent there’s an explanation, it’s not emergent anymore but has an upstream structure we can understand. If so, there’s our Platonic Space of patterns.
Therefore, we can talk about a Platonic or Latent space of non-physical truths.If you’re worried about adding new “realms”, sorry, I think there’s no way around it and we have to go where our findings take us – no one promised that monism would be guaranteed or useful at an early stage (which is where we are). The good news is that it’s not a commitment to mysterianism – mathematicians have been doing fine this way and what I’m proposing is a research program, not a retreat into an unknowable space.

Note also that if you say “the patterns really are just part of physics” then you’re forcing monism by cheating (re-definition) – in no practical way are the discoveries of mathematicians and physics overlapping in methodology.  But if you want to make the patterns part of physics by re-defining physics to mean “Everything of importance”, fine. Then I would say the term “physics” is mostly useless, and we really should just talk about its two major branches, which are quite distinct (you get to name 2 sub-realms, instead of realms) and we still need to try to understand how they relate and nothing below changes.
We cannot assume that these patterns matter only for math and are irrelevant beyond that.There is no good reason to limit Platonic hypotheses to mathematics, although that’s where it has mostly stopped in modern science. I’m dropping this axiom, that most everyone likes to take on. Fewer assumptions is better. Let’s examine the consequences of a broader view.
The field of diverse intelligence is helping to understand a continuum of intelligence agency all the way from extremely minimal systems through humans and beyond.See this paper for a deep dive into the spectrum. The key is a unification of systems with respect to their goal-seeking competencies and creative plasticity, regardless of their composition or origin story. The actual level of any system must be determined empirically (can’t be guessed philosophically). In other words, the field of diverse intelligence gives us the tools to think about a continuum (a space) of very different kinds of behavioral competencies, from extremely minimal to very sophisticated, and many that are very alien in the kinds of spaces they inhabit. This is an important conceptual skill to have.
I make the hypothesis that patterns will be relevant also to other disciplines well beyond mathematics.My specific framework proposes a huge space, whose denizens have been classified by us as belonging to different disciplines. From this view, math is simply the behavioral science of a type of pattern amenable to formal models, developmental biology is the behavioral science of cellular collectives navigating anatomical morphospace, etc.   Interestingly, many professionals have no issue with Dualism in mathematics, and no one is worried about an immaterial “algorithm” literally controlling the electron flows in a computer;  people are only allergic to these kinds of models when we claim the patterns are relevant to biology or cognitive science, and might themselves have higher-order agency.
Conclusion:  we can think of physical bodies (embryos, cyborgs, computers, etc.) as interfaces for a non-physical space of patterns that ingress through these interfaces to reveal to us specific behaviors. These patterns may be of highly variable agency. We should think of the mind-brain relationship as analogous to the math-physics relationship.Some of the patterns in that space are low-agency, like some mathematical facts that just sit there (e.g., value of e); some are slightly better, being simple dynamical systems (e.g., Liar paradox oscillators). Others have simple learning capacity as we showed for systems of coupled ODEs. Others are so dynamic and capable that behavioral scientists would recognize their competencies as behavioral propensities; i.e., they are kinds of minds.
Therefore, theories about the physical interfaces – like, the thermodynamic cost of computations, evolutionary theory, neural substrate for mind, etc. are importantly incomplete.Like with all thin-clients, studying the front end interface will be only part of the story, if the important information is on the back end of the server. I suspect almost everything we know is now up for revision, because we’ve been focusing on only one end of the story – the physical end.
Therefore, we don’t have to assume these patterns only constrain – they may offer enablements, which should be studied (quantified, predicted, benefitted from).This is possible because the “no free lunch” commitments are derived from the laws of the physical world. The Platonic Space seems to offer useful patterns for which the physical processes of learning, evolution, etc. do not need to pay (or, pay some, but receive much more than the effort they put in).   I think focusing on constraints is very limiting for discovery. I suspect that “physics” is what we call the study of systems that are constrained by these patterns, but “biology” and “cognitive science” (which I think is wider than biology) are what we call the study of systems that are potentiated and enabled by them (i.e., that exploit the patterns, and are indeed themselves patterns manifesting through embodiments).
Now we can ask specific questions:
A) Are the patterns unchanging and eternal?I don’t commit to that. There may be some, like e, but I think most of the interesting ones (like us – we are patterns on this view) are modified by their projections into the physical world (it’s a 2-way interface).  The naming is questionable; I chose Platonic Space because the mathematicians would immediately know what I mean and I could extend off of that, but I make no attempts to stick close to Plato’s views (to whatever extent we know).
B) Can patterns interact laterally within the space?We don’t know yet, but possibly. A mathematician thinking about abstract objects may be an instance of one (highly intelligent human) pattern resonating with a lower-agency feature of the space (the mathematical object).  Maybe there are other instances; maybe all memories are not stored in the living tissue (nevermind brain) and are partly a reconstruction from prompt patterns in the space.
C) Could it have been otherwise?I have no claims about how the Platonic space came to be, but we are getting data that may suggest it is somewhat fine-tuned to favor intelligence and agency (like the physical universe is seen to be). Stay tuned for that.
D) Are the contents of the space sparse or dense? Finite or infinite (and what grade of infinity?).We don’t know. I have no strong claims on this.
E) Isn’t it a problem to think the patterns somehow pre-exist their physical embodiments?I don’t know how to handle time in this kind of situation yet (interaction between physical events and non-physical patterns), so I won’t claim patterns pre-existed the physical world – it may not be a well-posed question in this situation. But, we do have to say why specific forms are the way they are (e.g., why it’s the 4-color theorem, not the 9-color theorem), which means that the patterns that emerge are from a specific biased distribution (that collapses to one outcome?) and that distribution has to “pre-exist” in some sense (causal, explanatory).
F) So what does the Platonic space actually offer – what degree of free lunches? How do we exploit them, in a measurably consequential form?This is a major part of the research program. We know the space offers static forms (value of e etc.) but perhaps also dynamic behaviors (policies), and possibly actual compute. We’re testing that now, in a range of simple computational systems (which make things easier to quantify) and biological ones (which offer more impressive and sophisticated examples of free lunches).
G) How best to study this space and its influence on the physical world?We need to build interfaces and fearlessly (and creatively) study what unexpected patterns ingress through them that are not well-explained by their history of selection, engineering, or learning from experience.  Biology (e.g., synthetic morphology) offers the most sophisticated patterns, but it’s very hard to prove anything in biology, so we’re also making minimal computational models where we can more easily quantify the effort put in and the outcome we observed.
H) Any hypotheses about who or what prepared the space, what the largest pattern in the space might be, etc.? Surely this supports ancient belief systems that would be comfortable with non-physical patterns?

Not from me, no. I know of no way to derive any normative claims from what we know about this field so far, or of any relevant data that favor a specific system over others. I do not encourage that kind of speculation from anything I’ve said. I do think this work (not just my lab’s) will drive major changes in areas of science, and also enlarge the scope of scientific inquiry itself. I do not support using that to shoehorn in various agendas beyond the (broad) scientific search for insight where-ever it leads.
I) Shouldn’t you abandon this line of inquiry because it might give cover to those who interpret it in favor of specific belief systems?It’s not our job to make sure that specific systems remain coverless, and I’m not going to avoid talking about what I really think is going on, out of fear that others may draw inappropriate conclusions, or just conclusions that we may not like. I may not be happy about it when that happens, but it’s a risk no matter what we say or do in science and philosophy and has always been true. The solution is not to bend from what we discover, but to better communicate to the wider public, as clearly as possible, what we think our observations do and do not say. Certainly scientific discoveries in physics, neuroscience, and evolutionary theory have been inappropriately interpreted in many ways (giving rise to the meaning crisis, etc.). I will address those issues elsewhere, eventually; I think this work is not unconnected to that, but it’s way too early to say anything concrete about it yet.

The specific research program suggested by these ideas is in progress in our lab and others (some of it is listed here but developing quickly so that’s going to be out of date continuously). This is all changing rapidly with new findings, so I may soon need to revise some or all of the above. That’s part of the fun of science. For now, the above summarizes my thinking in this area.


Featured image by Midjourney.

99 responses to “A short argument on Platonic Space: variable-agency patterns that in-form physics, biology, computer science, and cognitive science”

  1. Alexey Tolchinsky Avatar
    Alexey Tolchinsky

    Very useful summary, Michael. Much to think about. May I ask about this part: “There are facts which are not physical facts.”

    What is the definition of physical here? If we take any information, including this comment, has it not been encoded, stored and retrieved physically and required energy expenditure? How do we separate the non-physical from physical, on what basis?

    I realize Shannon’s work was an attempt to separate “information” from the transistors and everything else, but Daniel Dennett commented on this attempt in his “From Bacteria to Bach” book and his arguments seem convincing to me. Information that is clearly separated from energy expenditure and physical media seems to be in and of itself a belief. This line of thinking has a chance to be tautological – we claim that something is purely non-physical because we believe in “non-physical” as a construct. It can be a circular belief system.

    Can there be a scientific experiment that can disambiguate “physical” from “non-physical” and prove one or another?

    When we say that a belief exists out there without any physical representation, what data do we have to support the absence of physical representation?

    Any communication of this belief seems to be physical, the act of recognition or analysis is physical.

    I’d just like to see an example of a provably non-physical anything and what matters here critically is the boundary. Since we are discussing a pattern, a fact or the truth, presumably, this pattern is not swimming in quantum foam, but it is demarcated from other facts, truths, patterns – how? Is this separation non-physical? If so, how do we formally verify or prove the separability while relying on strictly non-physical items?

    __

    If we form a belief that there is such a thing as a perfectly flat plane, this belief does not occur in a vacuum; it occurs in a system capable of forming counterfactuals. Examples of such systems can be you, me, and a broader human collective intelligence mediated by language and culture. The belief is embedded in these systems. These systems use energy.

    Can a belief be separable from the system that it is embedded in? I don’t think so; it would lose meaning. The extraction of meaning from a belief is an active process that occurs within the system that holds it. And that system uses energy.

    1. Sean Miller Avatar
      Sean Miller

      I think Mike’s argument is that the truth-value of mathematics and logic is completely immune to physical entropy. If I write “17 is prime” in the sand, it costs physical calories. If a computer calculates it, it costs watts. If a brain thinks it, it burns ATP. So the *representation* of the fact is strictly physical and thermodynamically costly. But the *mathematical relationship* itself does not require energy to be true. When a physical calculator runs out of battery, the equation doesn’t die; the physical system simply lost the thermodynamic capacity to grip it.

      Put another way, meaning is not a property of the math itself. Meaning only ever announces itself in systems with valence and negentropic stakes.

      If you are uncomfortable with the timeless “space” of Platonic forms, instead of viewing these truths as ghostly objects floating in a void, you can view them through the lens of pure computation. This is essentially Wolfram’s concept of the Ruliad. If you imagine the space of all possible computational rules and logical permutations, mathematical truths act as inevitable, topological features within that space.

      They are like geometric attractors. When any complex system like a biological organism, a silicon computer, or the physical universe itself begins executing rules, it will inevitably bump into prime numbers, the Fibonacci sequence, and the laws of logic. These truths don’t need a magical, immaterial plane of existence; they are simply the inescapable constraints and necessary consequences of any system capable of holding information or executing a process.

      Now whether that’s a difference that makes a difference from a strictly Platonic ontology is debatable but some people find it more palatable.

      1. Alexey Tolchinsky Avatar
        Alexey Tolchinsky

        Sean, I’m simply trying to clarify the terms. Can you kindly provide your definition of “physical” or “non-physical”? Definitions, not examples.

      2. Mike Levin Avatar
        Mike Levin

        > These truths don’t need a magical, immaterial plane of existence; they are simply the inescapable constraints

        so, “magical” in the sense of impenetrable mystery? absolutely not. I claim this line of thinking is more generative for new research then the shoulder-shrugging “emergence” so popular today. Magical in the sense, not captured by today’s paradigms in that they don’t make it easy to see and exploit new useful phenomena? yeah I think so. Everything we do today is magic to the paradigm’s of 100 years ago, so it’s a moving target…

        “immaterial plane” – yeah I think we had that from Pythagoras and probably before. The truths of math cannot be derived from facts of physics. It’s a different domain with different tools and properties. Don’t call it a realm if you don’t want to; just focus on the tools used to study it. I take a very operationalist view to all this. If I can productively use the tools of electrophysiology and the concepts on non-neural cells, then it’s still neuroscience. If I can’t use the tools of physics to discover why e=2.78…, then it’s a different domain.

        1. Philip Spomer Avatar
          Philip Spomer

          I’ve noticed that despite the tremendous use of mathematics do to computers, the numbers show no signs of wearing out.

          1. Mike Levin Avatar
            Mike Levin

            Weirdly enough, I have a (fiction) story coming on this topic soon.

    2. Dave Grundgeiger Avatar
      Dave Grundgeiger

      I like these questions. But, while it’s true that every *discussion* of a Platonic ideal (eg the Platonic circle, the bubble sort algorithm) must be physically embodied, I don’t think this means that the ideal form itself is physical. Eg, I can read two different textbooks that each explain the bubble sort algorithm, but there is only one algorithm. It makes sense to me to call the implementations physical and the algorithm behind them non-physical.

      1. Alexey Tolchinsky Avatar
        Alexey Tolchinsky

        Thank you, Dave.

        Right, so when you segregate or separate the thing itself, e.g. an “algorithm” from its “substrate,” which you call “implementation” or, some might call “representation,” you do something non-trivial – you assume they are separable. On what basis can we assume that, it is not a trivial assumption at all. More on that:

        https://alexeytolchinsky.substack.com/p/context-is-key-to-separability

        I’m just trying to get clarity on what is the definition of physical, is it energy consuming? Having mass? Composed of matter? Abiding to the laws of physics? Depending on how the term is defined specifically, the conversation may change and also some of these things can be measured and falsified and some others not so much.

        I think that an attempt to separate any belief from a system that has this belief embedded in it is an attempt to de-contextualize. When is context is lost, we may lose the very ability to separate scales.

        Take any cultural phenomenon – e.g. nostalgia, or Pythagoras theorem within Euclidean geometry on a perfect (imaginary) plane. Can we interact with this idea without any matter present or any exchange of energy? If not, then what makes us think that it “exists” outside of our observation of it or interaction with it – other than a belief that “it exists”?

        Then, if a belief in the existence of a perfectly flat plane is a belief held by humans (physical systems). Such beliefs can be stable in the culture and can be shared, but on what basis do we consider them to be “non-physical?”

        Can we measure the energy exchange with any abstract concept and prove that it is zero and no matter was used in the exchange?

        Do we assume that the act of interaction/observation of any Platonic “thing” is unnecessary or that it does not change the object we interact with (if so, we might inadvertently throw away Quantum Mechanics and also contextuality and then we possibly can’t separate any longer).

        It is entirely possible that these concepts – “purely abstract”, purely “non-physical” are beliefs, which cannot be falsified, proven, or measured.

        Then, we possibly step away from empirical science, which is fine.

        I’m curious if we can have clear criteria of “non-physicality” and then a way to establish that more or less observer-independently?

        1. Nathan H Sweet Avatar

          Alexey, your separability question is the sharpest thing in this thread and I want to make sure it does not get buried.

          What you are pointing at has a name in the formal literature, the interaction problem, and it has been the central unresolved challenge to exactly this kind of position since Benacerraf raised it in 1973. The short version: if mathematical objects are genuinely non-physical, we cannot stand in causal relations with them, which means we have no standard account of how we access them. Mike’s version of the problem is actually more acute than the standard epistemological one, because he is not just claiming we know abstract objects. He is claiming they cause physical events. That requires them to produce detectable physical effects. But if they produce detectable physical effects, physical instruments can in principle detect them. And if physical instruments can detect them, they are physical in exactly the sense Step 1 of his argument requires them not to be. The argument needs non-physical status to establish the separate realm and causal efficacy to make that realm scientifically relevant. Those two requirements contradict each other, and no one has resolved that contradiction in fifty years of trying.

          Sean, the description you offered, mathematical truths as inescapable constraints and necessary consequences of any system capable of holding information, is actually a well-developed position in the philosophy of science called structural realism. Ladyman and Ross spent a book arguing for exactly that view. And the reason it matters whether we call it structural realism or Platonism is not terminological. It is empirical. If mathematical patterns pre-exist in a Platonic space and ingress through physical interfaces, you expect biological systems under novel conditions to converge on pre-existing attractors. If mathematical structures are formal invariances of physical constraint dynamics, you expect path-dependence: different starting conditions producing different historically constituted forms. Mike’s xenobot data shows massive variability depending on exact initial conditions. The forms are path-dependent. That is what the constraint account predicts. It is not what Platonic convergence predicts. So the two descriptions make different predictions about Mike’s own experiments, which means the choice between them is not just philosophical preference.

          Dave, the algorithm question is the intuition that makes Platonism feel obvious, and Alexey’s response to it is correct. The separability of algorithm from substrate is assumed in the framing, not established by it. In living systems specifically, the evidence suggests the constraint and the process it channels are mutually constitutive in ways that resist clean separation. The organizational closure literature, Montévil and Mossio 2015 is the primary reference, formalizes exactly why.

          What strikes me about this thread is that the three of you, without coordination, without the formal literature, just reading carefully and thinking honestly, landed on the same load-bearing cracks that philosophers of mathematics have been trying to fill for fifty years. That should tell you something about how deep the cracks go.

      2. Dave Grundgeiger Avatar
        Dave Grundgeiger

        I think it’s fine if you define “physical” in a way that assigns things that we think of as Platonic entities to that set. Eg my own working definition of “physical” is “everything that’s in a casual relationship with things that we are comfortable calling physical,” and I think that does include some things that I call Platonic entities. But I don’t think that matters for Levin’s ideas here. I think the key point is that there’s *some* important category distinction that Levin is describing as physical vs non-physical. You and I might choose a different metaphor, but I didn’t think that matters.

        1. Tony Budding Avatar
          Tony Budding

          Speaking of metaphors, there is one that can help frame these discussions and parse different categories of complexity regarding the mind-brain-body dilemma. The metaphor is photography. It works with different types of cameras, but I’ve chosen a digital SLR for convenience.

          With the physical camera, any changes to the lens, sensor, aperture, shutter speed, focus, or codec change the photos produced. If the lens is dirty, the pictures are affected. Therefore, one might conclude that the camera causes the photographs.

          But a camera does not just exist for its own sake. People make cameras for the purpose of taking and sharing photos. The photographer decides when to change or clean the lens, or play with various settings on the camera. The photographer is responsible for framing the image and determining when to take each photo. Two photographers using the same camera take different images.

          Once the original images are captured, they get filtered, with some selected and others discarded. Most photos are edited in some way before sharing. If the image is printed, there are variable processes required that affect the final image. If the image is shared digitally, the qualities of the screen it gets viewed on affect how it looks.

          Most importantly, photography is the capturing of light. The camera is useless without light.

          The physical camera is like the brain and body, including the senses. The codec is like the conversion of raw sense data into knowable content. The photographs are like our processed knowledge and experiences.

          Regarding the photographer, there is some sense of self driving the use of the brain and body, and a set of determined efforts driving what to focus on, capture and change. There is a selection and editing process in the generation and interpretations of our experiences.

          Now we have to ask about the light, without which the camera is useless. Some would say it is consciousness, but for that to be useful, we’d need a good definition of the term. Awareness and will are better terms in my opinion.

          Finally, when someone buys an art book of photography, they are typically only interested in the qualities of the images themselves. Most such books do not even include the details of the camera and lens used. Instead, the images are assessed based on the content and the impact on the viewer. In life, for most people, what matters is the qualities of their experiences, not which parts of the brain or body were active in their creation.

          Life is obviously more complicated than photography, but it is useful to parse these various elements. There has to be a physical infrastructure, but this physical infrastructure does not have any meaning without non-physical awareness and will. Changes in the physical infrastructure directly affect the experiences of it, but are not the full picture.

          Raw data requires interpretation, interpolation, filtering and editing to be useful. What are the agents performing these activities, and what are the variables involved?

          Trying to force all these elements into a single GUT (grand unifying theory) is literally impossible because they are categorically distinct. They certainly influence each other, but we can’t address the quality of the glass in the lens, the programming of the codec, and the artistic qualities of the final image produced with one theoretical approach.

          Similarly, we need different approaches for the measurable, shared physical realities, for unmeasurable Platonic phenomena, awareness, will and sense of self, for the causal infrastructure in which Platonic phenomena, awareness, will and self arise, and for how these three broad categories interact and influence each other.

          1. Alexander Neshmonin Avatar
            Alexander Neshmonin

            “Tony, your photography metaphor is excellent. In the Paradigm of the Great Life, I would add one layer: the ‘Light’ you describe is the Text. In a living Universe, electromagnetic waves are not just energy; they are transmissions from one Agent to another. The ‘Photographer’ is the Agency (the ‘Me’), which reads this Text and interprets it through its own Model of the Universe to create the ‘Photograph’ (Reality). This resolves the mystery of why two photographers see different worlds—they are using different Contexts to interpret the same Text!”

        2. Bill Miller Avatar
          Bill Miller

          If I understand correctly, I think the term “physical” as used in this context implies a phenomenon that is a product of mindless electro/chemical/mechanical forces (or pure randomness) as opposed to some sort of intentional, deliberative, mental/conscious agency.

          1. Mike Levin Avatar
            Mike Levin

            hmm I don’t know what “deliberative” means (if it’s meta-cognition, it’s a fairly high place on the spectrum – a lot to ask for!). When I use “physical”, I do not assume it’s mindless. What I mean is something like: “the kinds of things studied in third person by physicists”. The reason I harp on mathematical truths all the time isn’t that they’re the most important, they just offer the best contrast with the physical. They’re not found by experiments or any of the things physicists do. They can’t be changed by tweaking the things physicists can (at least in principle) change – like the constants governing the physical universe etc. I know many people who think it’s not a problem if we find that the speed of light or G slowly changes on the cosmological scale; no bid deal. I don’t know *anyone* who thinks it’s possible for the value of e to change over time. Somehow these are not the same… And I think it doesn’t require assumptions about which one is mindless to define the difference.

    3. James Cross Avatar

      Certainly, in one sense, there is probably nothing that is truly non-physical. However, that still misses something.

      Information has a dual aspect: its physical realization and its non-physical or abstract aspect in its informational pattern or meaning. They are not separate entities, but the abstract aspect of information is independent of a particular physical realization because it can be encoded in different ways. We can transmit a message in ASCII or Morse code – the physical message would be different but the message the same.

    4. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      Hi Alexey! Bet you all thought I’d never get to replying to all this! I found an hour… I appreciate all the discussion and good points. Here goes:

      > How do we separate the non-physical from physical, on what basis?

      ok so modern physics has already stretched “physical” so far that it looks nothing like the naive realism view. Don Hoffman, Chris Fields, etc. are taking it further – it’s kind of unrecognizable now. So maybe eventually the distinction has to fall. Chris’s latest talk – https://youtu.be/mYQlbKjaq4s – oof… Anyway. For me, I take an engineering operationalist approach. If I can’t study something, change it, exploit it, or have a deeply meaningful interaction with it, using the tools of domain A, then it doesn’t belong to that domain. If the all-knowing physics aliens wanted to change all the basic constants at the beginning of the big bang, they still couldn’t make e=17. I’ve now asked several theologians, just for fun, whether God could change e, and they all say no (even though he could make the speed of light me 3 m/s). Lots of people think gravitational constant can change, I know of no one who thinks change is possible for the amazing fact that there is no possibility of a general 6-degree polynomial equation, the way there is for quadratic equations. This means to me, it’s a different domain. Don’t call it a realm, whatever…

      > Can there be a scientific experiment that can disambiguate “physical” from “non-physical” and prove one or another?

      it’s not 1 experiment, it’s a research program. Person 1 will say “these things are just emergent order” and go on to do things. Person 2 will say “I’m looking for the upstream causes, and their potential range of competencies” and go on to do other things. Then we all see what each view enabled. I know of no way that saying that the truths of cybernetics, of math, etc. are physical is going to help anything. The tools are different, the implications are different. If you want to *define* “physical” as “everything that exists”, fine, but you will still need two different “sub-realms” with different approaches.

      > If so, how do we formally verify or prove the separability while relying on strictly non-physical items?

      we try to track back experimentally-relevant competencies and see where we end up. Sometimes we end up in good explanations based on facts of physics. Sometimes we end up in more useful explanations based on things that are not physics (facts of math, cybernetics, etc.).

      > Can a belief be separable from the system that it is embedded in? I don’t think so; it would lose meaning. The extraction of meaning from a belief is an active process that occurs within the system that holds it. And that system uses energy.

      I don’t know about beliefs – that word sounds like a claim about an active (embodied) agent. I have to think about whether any of the properties I attribute to patterns of navigational competency should be described as beliefs – I’m not sure yet. But if you want to know why you got 1 active process vs. another active process, the answer is often something that takes us outside of the system entirely. Godel already told us this would happen… Or, in a way I think he’d approve, you can flip perspective and say the System is not just the energy-using part, it’s also the other part, like facts about the mystical “algorithm” which coders write to *control* what happens, despite the truth of Maxwell’s equations governing the computer. If you ignore half of it, you get to keep monism but I think at huge cost in terms of insight and thus capabilities.

      I guess I could ask everyone the opposite question: is physicalism testable? Is it a view that could ever be disproven or is it a definitional, metaphysical assumption which is invulnerable to progress of any possible kind?

  2. Sean Miller Avatar
    Sean Miller

    Excellent and clear eyed summary. Feynman would approve!

    Question. If the rules of morphospace are Platonic, but taking a computational ‘step’ through that space costs physical heat, biological systems obviously cannot afford to blindly brute-force search for solutions.

    So what guides the grip? Does the physical pressure of thermodynamics itself act as the search algorithm? Meaning, do the mathematical ‘free lunches’ represent the paths of least thermodynamic resistance? Or do you envision other potential mechanisms for pattern ingression?

    1. Jacob Wiener Avatar
      Jacob Wiener

      I don’t know how to formulate this well, but maybe the pattern also does some of the work to find its embodiment just as the embodiment does some work to find the pattern.

    2. James of Seattle Avatar
      James of Seattle

      I’m no expert, but the question brings up active inference, the Free Energy Principle, and surprise minimization to my mind.

    3. Larry Pace Avatar
      Larry Pace

      evolution grips the world where the cost of access to coherence-improving information is locally minimized.

    4. James Cross Avatar

      That’s something I’ve thought about a lot. But the problem is in this framework, as I understand it, the patterns themselves are causative. Your suggestion would be that the patterns emerge from thermodynamic principle which makes more sense to me.

      I think the patterns are encoding information from the interactions that are occurring at the lower level. The cicada’s 13 year cycle is information about the population dynamics of the species in the ecosystems where the cicadas evolved. They are not causes but accumulations and outcomes of the interactions.

      1. Mike Levin Avatar
        Mike Levin

        “emerge” is too anemic to drive the necessary research program. Use the word if you want, but how we get to new findings isn’t to just call them accumulations and outcomes and move on, but to ask why specific things emerge vs. other things, why some of the patterns that emerge work like encoded problem-solving competencies (not the cicada thing in particular, other examples we’ve studied), why those competencies look just like behavioral propensities studied by cognitive scientists (a.k.a., kinds of minds), and what it means for us and the possibilities of sciences, engineering, and humanities.

        1. James S. Cross Avatar
          James S. Cross

          Thanks for the belated reply. I’m surprised you got back to this after all of this time.

          “Emerge” may be weak but “cause” raises the issue of explaining how the immaterial causes anything material. How could Platonic causality be proven without a physical mechanism for it to operate?

          1. Mike Levin Avatar
            Mike Levin

            I don’t lose/forget anything, I just put it on my calendar and things get asymptotically further toward infinity out in time…

            > How could Platonic causality be proven without a physical mechanism for it to operate?

            the assumption here is that all causes are traditional billiard-ball type of interactions, where there is a physical mechanism on both ends of the interaction. My answer is:
            1) that notion of causation has been killed off by physics and philosophy anyway…
            2) I know many people don’t like the kind of causation I’m talking about but some do and it’s an active field; Lauren Ross (a philosopher of causation) and I are writing a careful paper on this topic. But several papers and books on this exist already.
            3) I’m an engineer, and I’m less interested in the metaphysics and linguistics of causation and more interested in a sense of it that is helpful for engineering (which includes, relationships at all levels of the hierarchy). So for me, A causes B if and only if
            a) A is the most insightful (fruitful, generative) explanation of why we got B and not C,
            b) if A were different, B would be different (Judea Pearl’s counterfactual criterion)
            facts of math (and more broadly the patterns I care about) meet both criteria in many cases where B is a specific piece of physics or biology or computer science etc. It’s not an energy-passing interaction, but I think the assumption that it has to be, is an axiom and not a result, and we can drop it and see what it enables. Science is full of great discoveries made when we relax the “obvious” axioms.

            1. James S. Cross Avatar
              James S. Cross

              Physicalism doesn’t imply or require billiard-ball universe.

              The idea of a “billiard-ball universe” belongs to mechanistic materialism rooted in classical Newtonian mechanics. Physics has abandoned it without embracing Platonic forms. It is a matter of what can measured, versus intuited,

              Complexity theory tells us how forms “emerge” from the physical without resorting non-physical causation.

              1. Mike Levin Avatar
                Mike Levin

                ok but the quotes on “emerge” are telling; “emerge” is, I think, even more to be avoided than non-physical causation, for reasons I’ve written about. People don’t like non-physical causation because they’re worried it will lead to mysterianism. I think “emergence” is the ultimate mysterian conversation stopper, and causation (of whatever kind) is to be preferred for leading next research programs.

            2. Bill Miller Avatar
              Bill Miller

              I’m happy to see this discussion thread pick up again. As a layman, in view of presentations by yourself, Kastrup, Hoffman, Faggin, et al, I’m sort of “channeling” my own conception of the nature and function of the platonic domain. I would appreciate anyone’s thoughts on the following:

              My best guess is that platonic space exists as sort of a relational database of forms of varying (and accumulating) complexity — which aggregate into more complex patterns/forms based on the “views” observed by some sort of conscious agency — ultimately “instantiating” into experience-able phenomena in the spacetime domain.

              A central question that I and others seem to struggle with is in regard to the nature of the agency or attractor that assembles said forms into the functional phenomena of experience. It’s apparent that emergence or randomness are explanatorily insufficient on the one hand, as is some anthropomorphized “divine watchmaker” on the other.

              Perhaps this is a Godel-like scenario? — the impossibility of trying to use elements within our current set of knowledge to conceptualize something outside?

              To that point, it is difficult not to think in a linear time-dependent cause-and-effect reference frame (since that is the basis of all our experience). Yet how might things “work” outside of that?

              If ultimate reality is a block universe in block time, are cause-and-effect really meaningful concepts? Might it be that all patterns preexist superposed in potential form, and nothing actually “happens”. Rather, the various patterns of forms are simply attended to in a sequence through the focus of Consciousness? (Similar to the way we process the pre-existent patterns in a digital motion picture file.)

              This would seem to solve many current problems and paradoxes – for example how free will and determinism actually coexist. However it would require a radical redefinition of what “agency” actual means.

              (… well, that’s the gist of it. Nobel Prize or banishment?)

              1. Tony Budding Avatar
                Tony Budding

                Hi Bill, you’ve brought up a few questions around the limitations of knowledge and structures of thinking, which is the focus of my work. One of the great challenges in epistemology is that knowledge itself is unmeasurable. This leads to a chicken-and-egg dilemma in that we can’t know what phenomena such as knowledge, agency, consciousness, will (free or otherwise) or “ultimate reality” are without defining them, but we can’t define them without knowing what they are. It’s quite the conundrum.

                One of Mike’s frequent reminders to us all is that effective definitions and premises of cause and effect (or at least of sequential influences) must be predictive of future results, not just rearview explanations of past results.

                You’ve brought up several topics that are extremely difficult to approach, not to mention resolve. Therefore, an important step after proposing clear operational definitions and testable premises is to conjecture what criteria could be used to validate such definitions and premises. In other words, what are the criteria by which we can establish how we know? Once the criteria are established, we can evaluate various types of evidence, reasoning and conclusions against them.

                Rereading your comment, I would suggest that the most fruitful concept for this process of positing clear operational definitions and the criteria for evaluation is “ultimate reality.” You wrote, “If ultimate reality is….” which implies that there is an ultimate reality (singular) and we just don’t know exactly what it is yet.

                To get specific, here are some questions that can guide your inquiries:
                How do you know there is an ultimate reality (singular) vs a confluence of multiple causal phenomena?
                What criteria can be used to evaluate either side?
                What does it mean to know something?
                What is knowledge itself, where does it come from, what are its qualities, where does it exist?
                Are there any finite boundaries to knowledge, and if so, what are they?
                Is the human mind even structurally capable of knowing the ultimate reality or causal phenomena?

                Regarding the last question, consider the following:
                Human eyes are capable of perceiving less than 0.01% of the known electromagnetic spectrum.
                Human ears are capable of perceiving less than 0.01% of the known sound spectrum.
                Human noses are capable of perceiving less than 0.01% of what dogs can smell.

                If you wish to suggest that the human mind is capable of complete understanding of “ultimate reality,” by what criteria do you justify the premise that the human mind is over 10,000x more capable than our senses?

                The reason I say this is the most fruitful topic is that it inherently forces definitions and premises for the other concepts. In terms of supporting our collective efforts to better understand our experiences and world, positing specific criteria for validation is arguably the most beneficial. First, we can debate the criteria independent of the results, and then we can use the established criteria to drive experimentation. This keeps everyone paddling in the same direction, or at least speaking the same language.

                1. Bill Miller Avatar
                  Bill Miller

                  Thanks for the thoughts Tony! Regarding “we can’t know what phenomena such as knowledge, agency, consciousness, will (free or otherwise) or “ultimate reality” are without defining them, but we can’t define them without knowing what they are. It’s quite the conundrum.”

                  I think you’ve hit the nail on the proverbial head. Conundrum, paradox, Catch-22 — whether in language or math, it seems we can’t formally know something without making it a discrete, bounded, “A-Not A” phenomenon. However, it is then out of the platonic domain and in the spacetime world. We seem condemned to live in the “map” rather than the terrain. (As you point out, even using the term “ultimate reality” circumscribes ultimate reality.)

                  Reminds me of a Buddhist aphorism: “Those who say, don’t know. Those who know, can’t say.”

                  Yet I guess there *is* precedent. As I understand, we don’t really know what things like gravitation or the quantum world actually *are*, yet the effects are reliable enough that we can productively work with them. Regarding the platonic realm, maybe we’ll have to settle for something similar.

                  In one interview, Michael suggested that the Platonic domain may be difficult to conceptualize from our vantage point, but “it might show up as synchronicity”. (Hopefully I got that right.)

                  I sort of get that. Rather than mechanical cause-and-effect, it would seem to be more of a dynamic, probabilistic, even “living” affair — something we don’t control, but in relation to which we are not entirely passive. And the latter is probably our next epistemic challenge.

    5. Larry Pace Avatar
      Larry Pace

      Intelligence, life, and civilization advance by reducing the distance to coherent, ethically actionable information.

      Informational distance means the time, energy, uncertainty, dimensional occlusion, and action cost separating a system from the actionable information required to preserve or improve its coherence. Across physics, biology, cognition, technology, and culture, systems that survive and scale are those that reduce this distance more effectively than alternatives.

      In this view, evolution is not only survival of the fittest, it is the progressive refinement of mechanisms that shorten the path from signal to meaningful action. Brains, language, tools, markets, AI systems, institutions, and civilizations all function as distance-reduction architectures.
      Consciousness emerges when a system becomes recursively capable of modeling its own state, comparing possible futures, preserving memory, and selecting actions that minimize informational distance while maintaining long-horizon coherence.

      Ethically, Cybormone extends this principle by arguing that the most advanced intelligence does not merely seek the nearest actionable information, but the nearest ethically admissible actionable information across multiple agents and timescales.

    6. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      This is a critical question. It’s not clear to me yet how much thermodynamics will play a role. I don’t want to make claims I can’t substantiate quite yet, but it seems to me that there’s at least a possibility that the standard thermodynamics of computation limits do not actually hold, because they are theories of the front end only. If an algorithm can do useful work besides what you pay for in the steps of the algorithm, then we’re not doing the accounting properly. No strong claims here yet, just reminding ourselves that some assumptions may not hold. I doubt the patterns go down paths of least thermodynamic resistance – I kind of see the opposite – they take challenges that require strong local deviations from entropic gradients. They seem to be the opposite in sign to the laziness of entropy and the “surprise minimization” of the FEP. Maybe a balance of both is needed.

  3. Graham Lawrence Avatar
    Graham Lawrence

    I’m extremely fascinated by this stuff, but as Dr Levin is about a million miles above me and a million years ahead of me, I don’t really know where to start to learn how to think about it properly. I do fully accept that materialist reductionist “explanations” of the universe have been insufficient, particularly where cognition and consciousness are concerned.

    But this concept of Platonic space, for example – it may be useful and necessary for going down these kinds of theoretical roads, but I can’t decide whether it actually makes sense. I do actually appreciate that it might be both “true” and “unfalsifiable”, as it seems perfectly feasible to me that consciousness is an ontological primitive, and that seems unfalsifiable as well; if it is kind of the “substrate” of the universe, and interacts with embodied and constrained brains [and other patterned structures, apparently!], then it seems as if it would take a “God” to disentangle it for experimental purposes. (Although I suspect “God” is just a term used by the more intellectually naive for that consciousness substrate of existence, rather than some kind of “motivated” “being”. As arrogant as it could be to believe I can understand or explain the ground of existence with any confidence!) So if it also is true then I wouldn’t be so concerned about its “interactionism” being unfalsifiable. I should think that “all the oxygen has been removed, I can’t breathe” is also kind of unfalsifiable in the desperation of the moment, but utterly necessary for explaining that current state of existence, even without evidence of its unfalsifiability. I mean, we’ve already got interactionism in the apparent duality between that elusive phenomenological consciousness and underlying physically explicable neuroscience. (If it really is an interactionism problem, but that might be a kind of perceptual misunderstanding anyway, like the Buddha saying that there’s no east or west in the sky, and the distinction is only in people’s minds.) That’s not particularly well expressed, but I don’t know where I’m going!

    Another thing that concerned me was the idea of “causality” in prime numbers being somehow “responsible” for when the cicadas come out; I don’t see why that sort of thinking is necessary, when surely it would be perfectly explained by those killjoys, the materialist reductionists, in terms of the randomness of evolution. (Cicadas come up in year X, they get eaten, bam, they leave no descendants; the cicadas next door come up in year Y, they don’t get eaten, they reproduce; Cicadas come up in year Z, they get eaten, etc. I don’t see any causality from prime numbers there; there is just the accidental discovery by survivors of that apparently random distribution, if there is such a thing, which gets through the cracks between the more frequently breeding predators in the “divisible” years in between.) I imagine the geniuses out there will now jump on me and tell me what I should start learning about next, so that I can say something more worth paying attention to next time.

  4. David Ripley Avatar
    David Ripley

    Dear Dr. Leven. I have followed your research for years and find your discoveries fascinating and profound. My question is how a particular cell “knows” it is a “dog” cell versus a “cat” cell? Does this “awareness” originate during the union of a sperm and an egg? If not, when does a cell discover its identity and purpose and does this identity reside in each cell?

    Keep up your excellent work. It is truly a paradigm shift from the materialistic worldview. I hope your work facillitates research outside of biology.

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      I don’t know if there are any dog or cat cells. Human cells can build Anthrobots, and planarian cells of one species can build bodies of a different species. We have hardware specs (genomes) that default to a specific outcome of course, but cell groups have a lot of plasticity to interpret these DNA prompts. https://www.cell.com/trends/genetics/fulltext/S0168-9525(25)00077-0

  5. Christopher Judd Avatar

    Possibly one of the issues with experts within the academic and science field generally is that they may be too constrained for finding novel solutions.

    I point people to the Holodynamic Pattern Theory which was created abductively from the evidence by a non expert. Now it cannot be the lat word in explaining our ontology but its a bloody good start.

  6. Greta Jane Lockwood Avatar
    Greta Jane Lockwood

    I’m curious whether morphogenesis should be modeled primarily as signaling across a network of discrete cells, or as the stability of electrical field attractors in a continuous conductive medium, with cells acting locally to maintain and repair the field configuration. That distinction seems like it could matter a lot for how we think about regeneration, cancer, and morphogenetic control.

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      Yes; I think this was to a large extent Burr’s vision back in the 1940’s. There’s so much to do here. Also, on field configurations using cells to enable them to change (not necessarily stabilize).

  7. Tony Budding Avatar
    Tony Budding

    This is fantastic Mike. It’s so rare and inspiring to see someone grapple with paradigm shifts while keeping a full commitment to experimentation and methods of validation, along with a large degree of transparency and open dialog. As you know, I am attempting a related paradigm shift in epistemology and philosophy of mind. One of my primary efforts is to define the finite structures and boundaries of human cognition, which definitely overlaps with your exploration of Platonic space (which I call the experiential realm). And in that spirit (pun intended), I would like to plant some thought seeds for you as develop protocols for a scientific approach to the Platonic.

    1. The boundaries of cognition are extremely relevant because there are phenomena that we literally cannot conceive of. We infer these phenomena when knowable effects cannot be caused by knowable phenomena. The best we can do with inconceivable phenomena is construct theoretical models that predict knowable phenomena. And of course, the scope and accuracy of these predictions determine the value (or lack thereof) of the model.

    2. The rules of behaviors for measurable phenomena (which you are calling physics) are different from the rules of behaviors of unmeasurable but knowable phenomena (which you are calling Platonic space and math). There is some overlap with them, along with important bidirectional (or multidirectional) influences across the realms. Many of these influences are variable, which complicates experimentation. I can describe some of these variables if you’re interested.

    3. Be very careful with the concept of space. You call this alternate realm Platonic space, which naturally gets associated with the space of physics. Physical space has characteristics and boundaries that do not necessarily apply to the Platonic space (again, borrowing your language).

    4. Putting the above together, space and time (though I prefer the terms dimensionality and the sequencing of cause and effect) are the core infrastructure for human cognition, which means we cannot conceive of any phenomena devoid of space and time. This is a limitation of human cognition that does not necessarily apply to the Platonic or that in which the Platonic might inhere. I say “might” because while everything conceivable in the Platonic has manifest boundaries (by definition) and we need some causal infrastructure in which these boundaries inhere, whatever that may be is inconceivable using human cognition. Excluding that in which it might inhere creates an artificial hard limitation to determining cause and effect relationships.

    I recognize that these are bold claims. The purpose of my (forthcoming) book is to both thoroughly explain them and justify them through logic and knowable phenomena (which is why the book is so long). But I am not trying to convince anyone of them here. I write them in the hopes of helping you orient your approaches.

    For example, if space and time (dimensionality and sequencing of cause and effect) are the core infrastructure for human cognition (they are), then we have to allow for the possibility that the origins of both Platonic and physical spaces are outside or independent of space and time. We cannot know what this is like, but it does mean that we should assume that they are not limited by the constraints of space and time. To be clear, this is VERY difficult to work with conceptually. Without it, though, we impose limitations that may not (almost certainly do not) apply to the causal origins of both spaces.

    Along with this, there is no reason to assume that there are just two spaces. This is another reason I prefer the term realm to space. What you are approaching as Platonic space could very well be (most likely is) multiple different realms with different rules of behaviors. This does complicate your endeavor, but assuming it is one coherent space is a limitation that may not (almost certainly does not) apply.

    Finally, a few thoughts regarding your metaphysical stance on order versus randomness of Platonic phenomena. First, based on my work, I have no doubt that at least some Platonic phenomena are ordered (all of it may be, but we can’t know that).

    Second, be careful with bifurcations. Order and randomness are not necessarily the only options. There may be (probably are) inconceivable processes that we would not call order or randomness. Perhaps this is another category of order, but since we cannot conceive of it, we cannot know. Forcing a bifurcation is another limitation that needn’t occur.

    And third, be careful with assumptions regarding order. Order can be based on codependencies. What I mean is that some of the order we determine as globally or universally applicable to either/both physical and Platonic spaces could be based on conditions that have arisen in one instance that could be different in other instances. In other words, the order found in both spaces could be determined by this instance of this universe. As such, they might apply universally in this instance but be different in other instances. There is no reason to conclude that our universe is the only option, especially considering the limitations of conceivable conclusions.

    You have already pushed the boundaries of what is considered science, and you are just beginning. The further you push, the more relevant the finite structures and boundaries of human cognition become. It has been a pleasure and privilege to watch your work evolve, and I am excited to see how far you take it.

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      Thank you Tony, always appreciated.

  8. Josh Mitteldorf Avatar

    I welcome the expansion beyond the mechanism world-view, especially coming from a scientifically informed perspective, aware of the need not to discard any of Western science’s hard-won triumphs.

    But I regard the greatest challenge to be the explanation of remote viewing, precognition, and psychokinesis. I don’t see how Mike’s Platonic realm moves us closer to this.

  9. George Overholser Avatar
    George Overholser

    Excellent and thought provoking as always.

    Some questions about the “free lunch” line of reasoning.

    What were the evolutionary costs of the unanticipated uses of Kauffman’s screwdriver?

    Do those unanticipated (and un-selected upon) uses necessarily arise from the Platonic realm?

  10. Mike Levin Avatar
    Mike Levin

    Thanks everyone, great discussion as always. I will reply to a bunch of the points as soon as I can – drowning in deadlines this week.

  11. James Cross Avatar

    I’m really not seeing that the patterns are causal argument.

    Would cicadas come out in 13 and 17 cycles even in the absence of predation cycles? And why 13 and 17? Why not 5, 7, and 11 too? Why just cicadas? Why not flies? Why not all cicadas, since some come out yearly?

    Strategies like these evolve from complex feedback between organisms in the environment, not because of patterns from a Platonic Realm. If the predator populations dropped every four years, there would a 4 year cycle.

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      Let’s try it this way. There are certain things that are possible and impossible for reasons best explained by a theorem of cybernetics, for example. There are capabilities of *random* networks (not evolved, not designed) that look very much like the things we study in behavior science. You can’t pin it on evolution, or on physics. There are other sources we absolutely need to understand, and Kauffman’s Order for Free just scratch the surface – that’s my point.

  12. Ian Todd Avatar
    Ian Todd

    I really think a mathematical notion of dimensionality is key.

    Low dimensional systems collide, they calculate, they enact logic.

    High dimensional systems are non-colliding. Everything is connected to everything. They follow a kind of logic, but differently. “This statement is a lie” is an oscillator in high dimensional space.

    Intelligence is the emergent property of high dimensional systems resisting decoherence: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0303264726000146

    Platonic space is a high dimensional space.

  13. Alexander Neshmonin Avatar
    Alexander Neshmonin

    It is a pleasure to see your latest thoughts on Platonic Space. About two years ago, I reached out to you regarding my book “Changing the Paradigm of Life: New Answers to the Old Questions.” Seeing this argument for “Platonic Space” and “Variable-Agency Patterns” feels like a powerful confirmation of our shared trajectory. However, our starting points and “architectural” conclusions differ in ways I believe are vital for the research program you’ve outlined.

    *The Core of the Paradigm of the Great Life*
    My work moves the Universe from a current “Great Graveyard” of dead matter to a “Great Life”, based on a single foundational assumption, called Dualogy:

    *All phenomena of Reality should be considered from both perspectives – Metaphysical Realism and Metaphysical Anti-Realism. I.e., Reality is fundamentally twofold (dual), with two complementary sides – objective and subjective.*

    The book shows how the following consequences logically follow from this statement:

    • *Life as a Membrane*: Reality consists of the Realm of Energy (objective hardware) and the Realm of Information (subjective software). Life is the active, two-sided Membrane between them.
    • *The Me-Universe Drive*: Evolution is a process of Cognition that is driven by the fundamental contradiction between the “Me” (the Agent) and the “Not-Me” (the rest of the Universe). Each Agent has its own Model of the Universe – a reflection of the behavioral scheme it adapts to maintain its homeostasis. The goal of the evolution is to discover a Fully Adequate Model of the Universe.
    • *The Universal Hierarchy*: Evolution does not start with the cell; it starts with the Proto-living Agent (which turns out to be the elementary particle). This hierarchy scales up through cells and organisms to Superintelligent Agents (Stars) and Super-Superintelligent Quasi-organisms (Galaxies and clusters).
    • *Info-cloning*: This is the mechanism of cosmic stability. Once an Agent (like an atom, a cell, or a being) discovers a successful Model of the Universe, Life stabilizes that state through Info-cloning – replicating the successful informational “instruction manual” across the Realm of Energy.

    If you want the details, I’ve compiled these ideas into a series of short videos (https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZR5Ut8hWTyT0vhRDO_PtzH1NPDv2c0It), which I believe provide a structural “Dualogy” that could serve as a robust framework for your research program. There’s one problem with these videos, though: they’re not a very good translation from Russian. The Russian version uses the author’s term “Субъектность,” which should be replaced with the generally accepted “Agency.” But in the English translation, “Субъектность” has become “Subjectivity,” which often implies mere passive experience in the English-speaking context. However, in our context, it must imply the capacity for an entity to be a Subject of action – an Agent.

    *Resolving the Paradoxes of Physics*
    This “Agentic” approach allows us to resolve paradoxes that the “Graveyard” paradigm cannot:
    • *Quantum Mechanics*: A wave is an Agent that has not yet been “born” (pure Information). A particle is the moment of Agentic Birth (Wave Function Collapse) when it receives Agency through interaction.
    • *Thermodynamics*: We avoid “Heat Death” because every Agent in the hierarchy is actively lowering its own entropy through cogCognition • *Cosmology*: I suggest interpreting Redshift not as expanding space, but as the result of the Universe’s accelerating Info-Density. Agents (atoms) adjust their “pulse” to keep the flow of subjective time constant.

    *Where Our Paths Diverge: Pattern vs. Text*
    Your “Platonic Space” is a realm of patterns that “ingress” into physics. I find this brilliant, but I propose a deeper layer. In my view, Information is not a pattern; it is Text.
    A pattern is a constraint; a Text requires an Interpreter. In my Dualogy, the “Agency” isn’t just in the Platonic pattern; it is the act of the Agent Entity reading that Text within its own Context to build its Model. This explains the “Free Will” we see at every level: the Agent isn’t just following a Platonic “server”; it is interpreting the broadcast.

    *Application for Developmental Biology*
    You ask about the “free lunches” and computational costs of Xenobots. In my framework, the “cost” is paid by the Agency of the Cells. When you change their environment, you change their Context. The cells, as Agents with their own Models, read this new “Text” and – through Info-cloning and Agentic Negotiation – reorganize into a stable Quasi-organism. They are not just “pulling down” a pattern; they are collaborating to solve a new problem of homeostasis.

    Warm regards,
    Alexander Neshmonin

    1. Alexander Neshmonin Avatar
      Alexander Neshmonin

      I was very excited after reading your article and obviously rushed my previous comment, which made it sound jumbled and unclear. I’m afraid it looks like a shameless advertisement for my book, which was absolutely not my intention.

      I was that excited because your article essentially moves science toward the realization that the “Great Graveyard” is a conceptual error. By treating the mind-brain relationship as analogous to the math-physics relationship, you are effectively “Agentizing” the fabric of Reality.
      However, there are deep architectural differences between your “Platonic Space” and my Dualogy.

      1. The Nature of Information: “Geometric Pattern” vs. “Semantic Text.”

      You describe “Platonic Space” as a structured realm of mathematical patterns – fractals, primes, and symmetries – that are “discovered” and “ingress” into physics. It is a space of possibility that physics is constrained to follow.
      In my Dualogy, the Realm of Information is more dynamic. I treat information not just as a static “pattern,” but as Text. A Text requires an Agent Entity to read and interpret it within a specific Context. This is a crucial distinction: in your view, the pattern is the rule; in my view, the pattern is a signal that must be cognized by an Agent to build its Model of the Universe.

      2. The Role of Life: “Thin Client Interface” vs. “Active Membrane.”

      You use a computer science metaphor: physical bodies (cells, embryos, robots) are “thin clients” or interfaces to the “server” of Platonic Space. The body doesn’t create the behavior; it merely “pulls it down” or manifests it from the latent space.
      In the paradigm of the Great Life, Life is not merely an interface; it is the Active, Two-sided Membrane. Life is the process of interaction between the Realm of Energy and the Realm of Information. It is the active translator that organizes Energy through Information, and Information through Energy. While your “interface” suggests a more passive reception of patterns, my “membrane” emphasizes the active, metabolic struggle of an Agent to maintain its boundaries and identity.

      3. The Me-Universe Paradox: “Unified Space” vs. “Disorganized Colony.”

      Your framework is currently open to the idea of “supra-human agencies” and does not explicitly rule out a unified structure to the Platonic Space. This edges toward the idea of a single “Platonic Mind” (i.e., “Universe as the Total Organism” idea).
      The paradigm of the Great Life is much more vigilant about the Me vs. Not-Me contradiction. It explicitly defines the Universe as a disorganized colony of diverse Agent Entities (stars, galaxies, cells) rather than a single Super-Intelligent organism. The paradigm argues that if the Universe were a single “Me,” the contradiction that fuels Life would vanish. You seem focused on the source of the patterns, while I am focused on the autonomy, competition, and cooperation of the Agents who use them.

      4. The Scale of Physics: “Mathematical Constraint” vs. “Stellar Agency.”

      Your work is largely anchored in developmental and synthetic biology – cells and tissues navigating morpho space. When you speak of physics, you see math as a “constraint” on fermions and symmetries.

      The paradigm of the Great Life applies the Agency of the “Platonic” realm directly to the Stellar Hierarchy. Where you might see the “Golden Ratio” as a mathematical free lunch exploited by a plant, I see the Stellar Superintelligence (the Sun) as an Author broadcasting Texts to its peers and subordinates. I move the “math department” into the realm of Social Interaction at a cosmic scale, explaining things like Redshift and Galaxy rotation not as mathematical constraints but as the deliberate, coordinated behavior of high-level Agents.

      Hope this sounds more articulate now 😊.

      Yours,
      Alexander Neshmonin

  14. James of Seattle Avatar
    James of Seattle

    Thank you for this nice summary. I think the format was highly effective, especially for those like myself, philosophical amateurs.

    You don’t mention it specifically, but I’m wondering how you think this work relates to consciousness. I bring that up because I’ve been thinking hard about consciousness for more than a decade, and I’ve come to the conclusion that the fundamental basis of consciousness is pattern recognition. For me, the lowest level of this recognition involves the cell surface receptor + the mechanism that responds. I expect you might find other very simple mechanisms involving bioelectricity etc. But I’m more interested at getting to the higher levels, and so, compound, hierarchical forms. To me it looks like pattern recognitions of pattern recognitions, all the way up. I’m just wondering if you have any related thoughts.

    *

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      I don’t have any strong claims about consciousness (except some skeptical stances on the existence of any “unconscious processes” and such). But if I had to say something, I might say that consciousness is what we mean by the first person experience of a pattern ingressing into the physical world. Here’s some more: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxmSCElKdm0&list=PL6SlweOjqYXzKV6C63v17Y_hm8EXKW7wv

  15. Alexey Tolchinsky Avatar
    Alexey Tolchinsky

    I’d like to clarify, as what I wrote sounds overly confident. None of this is obvious. What you wrote, Michael is a viewpoint that absolutely has its place, it is thought-provoking and viable.

    When I seek clarity, I realize that clarity is a trade-off. Clear things tend to be generalizable, they have less details. Less clear things may be technically a higher fit to the data, but they may resonate with less people.

    Finally, these are all models. You have an empirical preference, which is truly unique and admirable, – many people are perfectly content with their opinions without any empirical verification.

    At the risk of being trivial, (Chris Fields is much better at this), in physics the question of what is and what is not physical has evolved and is not fully resolved yet – there are debates. “Physical” has changed from Newtonian inertial mass to Einstein’s famous E = mc^2 in special relativity (mass-energy equivalence) to space-time curvature in his general relativity, then to the excitation of a fundamental field in QM.

    Landauer extended Shannon’s work and proposed that erasure/forgetting of information generates heat – then information is physical (in the thermodynamic sense) and it seems that his thesis was subsequently was proven experimentally.

    So if information is “physical” in that sense, then all platonic forms are physical in that sense? – that is one of the possible viewpoints.

    Subsequently, Vopson suggested that information had mass – and I am not sure if this was proven just yet.

    Then, there is Chris Fields, who shifted the focus from “information as a substance” to “information as an interaction.” and things become even more interesting.

    To summarize, in physics, there are some frameworks, in which information is physical. And certainly there are frameworks elsewhere where information is not physical. Both exist. The history of “non-physical” ideas is long and well-developed.

    I think that clarifying the working definition of physical and non-physical can be helpful.

    Here’s a summary from our buddy Gemini (yes, I asked her)

    “The state of science regarding the physical and non-physical suggests that the distinction is largely a matter of scale and perspective rather than a fundamental ontological divide. Information is physical because it has an unavoidable energy cost, follows the laws of thermodynamics, and is instantiated in physical states that possess mass and spatial extension.”
    __

    What is important here is that your text and questions drive this forward and you’re open to experiments and various possibilities. You’re data-driven and flexible and that’s valuable. It’s all good!

  16. Taotuner Avatar

    Informational-Processual Monism is a philosophical proposal developed by Taotuner that offers a unified (monistic) view of reality, in which everything reduces to dynamic informational processes in physical systems far from thermodynamic equilibrium. From this perspective, consciousness is not a separate phenomenon or a “magical” emergence, but a natural intensification of these processes through recursive self-reference and self-sustaining causal integration.
    Taotuner. (2026). Informational-Processual Monism. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18970336

  17. Benjamin J Schulz Avatar
    Benjamin J Schulz

    If I were to pick a singular field of mathematics that could be instantiated throughout the hierarchical chain of elementary matter to living beings, I would choose topology.

    https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.25760

    1. Benjamin J Schulz Avatar
      Benjamin J Schulz

      One recent example where topology is seemingly the universal ” language”

      Vascularization of all animals follows specific set of topological rules.
      https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.04.10.717729v1

  18. Bill Miller Avatar
    Bill Miller

    An analogy occurred to me that might be useful. In the computer world (at least when I was involved) programming involved two domains. There were the higher user interface languages like COBOL, C, Java, Python, and then the machine-level assembly language understood by the computer. A compiler interfaced between the two. Sophisticated and useful applications could be written in the high-level languages while remaining completely oblivious to the underlying machine code.

    It seems the current effort to understand the “assembly language” of Platonic space may be a similar affair. Not to imply that such space must be algorithmic – just that may be the necessary “pointer” at the moment.

    The difficulty lies in trying to understand and conceptualize something outside of our experience set, using only elements within the current set – i.e. if it can be put into words, it’s probably no longer within Platonic space. (Makes me think back to your dialogue with Iain McGilchrist.)

    Yet perhaps as in the case of gravitation or the quantum world, we can work usefully with Platonic space based on its effects in our domain, while the phenomenon in itself remains mysterious?

  19. nathan pellegrin Avatar
    nathan pellegrin

    Thank you for this post, and for the broader body of work you’ve been sharing. Your intellectual stance is bold and honest, which I greatly appreciate! Like others, this post strikes me as both insightful and far-seeing.
    One way to sharpen the research program you’re outlining is to formalize it across three coupled layers. This framing is intentionally agnostic with respect to whether the latent space is “non-physical” in a strong ontological sense, or instead reflects structured regularities inherent in physical or computational systems.
    1) Latent pattern space (pattern space / latent space)
    A structured space of relational invariants, affordances, and possible behaviors. I would be very interested to hear more about how you understand and operationalize this latent space. It is not merely a catalog of static forms, but a topology of constraints and enablements which can, in principle, be realized. One way to think about it is as a structured space of possibilities; whether it is appropriate to treat it as a “field” with its own independent dynamics remains an open and important question.
    2) Interface (physical/biological system)
    Embodied systems (e.g. assemblages of cells, tissues, organisms, machines) that couple to this space. Interfaces are not passive; they define admissible queries into the space: what regions of pattern space can be accessed, stabilized, or explored. Different interfaces may expose very different portions of the same underlying structure.
    3) Realized pattern (observed behavior/form)
    Concrete instantiations: morphologies, competencies, policies, and dynamical trajectories. These are the measurable outcomes of a particular interface engaging the latent space, and the primary empirical basis for constraining hypotheses about its structure.
    The distinction between space, interface, and realization is not necessarily ontological, but may be understood in terms of explanatory and operational levels. Framed this way, the key scientific question becomes:
    When we observe novelty, how do we determine which layer it belongs to?
    The goal is not to assume a separate realm, but to ask what kinds of empirical signatures would require positing structured latent regularities beyond standard material explanations.
    Some provisional criteria:
    Material-level novelty (interface-local): If a novel behavior can be accounted for by known mechanisms plus historical selection or training, even if complex, then it is plausibly reducible to the interface.
    Interface expansion (new coupling): If modest interventions (e.g., bioelectric reconfiguration or architectural changes in a model) unlock disproportionately large new competencies, this suggests that the interface has accessed previously unavailable regions of the space.
    Field-level structure (latent regularity): If similar behaviors arise across disparate substrates with minimal shared history (biological, computational, synthetic) and especially if they can be predicted from abstract constraints such as topology, symmetry, or optimization, this points to structured regularities in the latent space itself.
    Field modification (strongest claim): If the space of attainable behaviors itself appears to change, such that new classes of stable patterns become accessible in ways not attributable to interface variation alone, this would be evidence, still hypothetical, that the space is not static but co-constituted.
    This framing also clarifies what would count as progress: not a final decision about the ontology of the latent space, but a tightening loop in which we build novel interfaces, observe unexpected competencies, quantify the gap between historical inputs and realized outcomes, and determine whether that gap is best explained by interface dynamics or by structured affordances in the space itself.
    In that sense, your critique of “emergence” resonates strongly. “Emergence” often names the boundary of our current interface rather than the absence of structure, and contributes, as you point out, to ‘mind blindness’
    Finally, this approach preserves what seems to me methodologically essential: maximal openness to empirical novelty. Rather than overfitting explanation to existing physicalist narratives or prematurely reifying metaphysical commitments, we can let experimental systems progressively constrain what must be true about the space of possible forms and intelligences.
    If this tri-layer framing is helpful, I would be very interested to hear your thoughts on the evolution of novelty: how novelty is assigned, detected, and measured, and especially how one might develop formal measures of interface capacity and “free lunches” (e.g., disproportionate gains in competency relative to thermodynamic or training inputs) that would make these distinctions operational.

    Thanks, again!

  20. Benjamin L Avatar

    Economics may be an interesting in-between case. Changing physics doesn’t seem to change math, but changing economics might: math contains economic structure, as I argued in Platonic space symposium, so changing economics should change math.

    Economics has also long had an axiomatic character to it that is peculiar for a science. There’s a logic to economic behavior that doesn’t seem to be much influenced by physics, if at all.

    Here’s JA Scott Kelso (precursor to the work people like Josh Bongard do) on the mind:brain relationship:

    > It is not unusual for scientists and artists to draw a dichotomy between brain and mind. For example, Henry Miller (1891–1988), the American writer and painter, remarks that ‘nothing happens in the brain except the gradual rust and detrition of cells’. ‘In the mind’, however, ‘worlds unclassified, undenominated, unassimilated, form, break, unite, dissolve and harmonize ceaselessly’ (emphasis mine). ‘In the mind-world’, Miller continues, ‘ideas are the indestructible elements which form the jewelled constellations of the interior life. We move within their orbits, freely if we follow their intricate patterns, enslaved or possessed if we try to subjugate them. Everything external is but a reflection projected by the mind-machine’ [86 p. 29]. The parallel between Miller’s mind and the multi- and metastable coordination dynamics of the brain described here is obvious. Mind and brain are complementary: they share a common underlying dynamics.

    Source: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstb/article/367/1591/906/45602/Multistability-and-metastability-understanding

  21. Osimresearch Avatar
    Osimresearch

    Dr. Levin, your argument on Platonic Space—specifically the idea that agency patterns in-form physics and biology beyond simple selection—aligns deeply with our work in Forensic Cosmology.

    We’ve been documenting what we call the “Sovereign Blueprint,” which treats these non-local patterns not as abstract math, but as the structural “Hull” of a physical biological sanctuary. When you look at the sheer efficiency of these systems—what we call the 20-Watt Rule—it supports the conclusion that we aren’t in a digital simulation. Biology isn’t “software” running on a server; it is the ultimate physical hardware, a specialized Life-Raft designed to sustain consciousness against entropy.

    Your work on Xenobots and neural healing provides the exact forensic markers we would expect to see in a managed biological sanctuary. We’re moving toward a “Who-Neutral” stance to focus purely on these observable mechanics of the Blueprint.

  22. Benjamin L Avatar

    How does Platonic space interact with the anatomical compiler idea? Some morphological structures will be much more stable than others for physical reasons such as weight distribution. Does Platonic space further constrain things, or is it the source of those physical constraints?

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      This is a really important point. So,
      1) it’s not just about physics: there are truths of cybernetics that constrain what happens and they rely on no aspect of physics.
      2) it’s not just about constraints: some of these patterns are massive enablements (free lunches) which evolution exploits greatly.
      3) it’s not just about stability: I think the drive is not to persist, it’s to change and grow (in some sense).
      Long before our bioelectric stuff, with patterns that electric circuits can pull down, the answer to why the chemical body-setting Turing Patterns and other reaction-diffusion mechanisms had this or that property was always “go see the math department”. I think Turing saw all this clearly – it’s not a coincidence that he was interested in math, new embodiments for intelligence, and embryonic patterning (as in his famous 1950’s paper).
      For us, the anatomical compiler is going to help identify which kinds of morphogenetic thoughts can be hosted by which kinds of systems, what other thoughts those thoughts can spawn off under what circumstances, and what stimuli/signals we can give these basal agents to push them towards more health-compatible thoughts. Thoughts being patterns with degrees of computational and congitive capacity in spaces like anatomical morphospace, transcriptional space, physiological state space, etc.

  23. Henri Koppen Avatar
    Henri Koppen

    Language, the ultimate platonic space 🙂

  24. zkzk Avatar
    zkzk

    i dont think all patterns exist, but some patterns exist. can we seek and re-geometric-ize 😳 (agency to change ones geometry), to oscillate, orbit and harmonize.

  25. Tyrone White Avatar
    Tyrone White

    Great summary, really clarifying to see the argument laid out step by step like this.
    The distinction between physics as the study of systems constrained by patterns versus biology and cognitive science as the study of systems enabled by them is one of the most striking reframings I’ve encountered. I wonder whether that line holds cleanly at the quantum scale though, where physics itself starts looking less like pure constraint and more like systems exploiting structure (interference, entanglement as a resource, etc.). Maybe quantum physics is already partially on the “enabled by” side of that divide?
    Separately, and partly inspired by your point about building minimal computational models to quantify what you get out versus what you put in: I built an interactive simulation of 25,600 coupled logistic map agents (logisticplatonic.space). Each cell is chaotic on its own, but coupling them to neighbors produces spontaneous collective order, domain formation, and self-repair after perturbation. Some parameter trajectories produce patterns resembling Persian rugs or biological morphologies, which is striking given how minimal the rule is.
    I’m curious where coupled maps like this sit relative to the minimal computational models you’ve been working with (like sorting algorithms). They seem like natural ground for discovering unforeseen behavioral patterns since you can precisely control coupling and topology, but they’re already quite dynamical compared to sorting, which might make it harder to cleanly quantify the “free lunch.” Is there a sweet spot you’re aiming for in terms of model complexity?

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      Yeah… I don’t know what’s happening at the quantum level and whether those things are relevant here. I’m more interested in cybernetics, whose theorems are half-way between math and psychology and are not dependent on truths of physics. As for coupled maps, yes! I’ve been studying them. Not sure if it’s paying off yet, stay tuned. As for the sweet spot… The issue is that biology offers the most amazing free lunches, but because we don’t know all the mechanisms, it’s impossible to prove or quantify much of interest for this question. Minimal computational models offer smaller free lunches, but at least there we know exactly what is and isn’t provided and who paid for it. So for now I’m working both sides. Maybe there will be a meeting point, or maybe I just keep going with both. Not sure yet.

  26. Zach Collins Avatar
    Zach Collins

    It’s funny how reading this and the comments is so clarifying about how tiny assumptions about words send a lot of things that likely do agree in principle off chasing different directions on what those words imply. Ambiguity really does do most of the lifting huh.

    I see it. I think it reminds me of propositional universes. It’s a small reframing that doesn’t impose but it does clarify by allowing more relational wiring that happens to not contradict as easily.

  27. Jack Kalvan Avatar
    Jack Kalvan

    Dr. Levin, I am a big fan of your insights on biology and diverse cognition.
    Here are my thoughts on your non-physicalism arguments:

    We model reality, using patterns that we see in things.
    Numbers are an imaginary human creation that we use to model groups of material things that exist. The material things exist; the numbers are only a model we make when we count them. (I would say numbers don’t exist, but this is just semantics, not important.)
    Patterns and spaces of possibilities are other tools we use to model what exists (or could exist).
    The point is: these are human-made models and can not be the cause of anything.

    The fact that cicada cycle in periods that are prime numbers is not caused by prime numbers. Cicada ancestors probably “tested” many different durations in their eons of evolution and the ones that competed least often had a survival advantage. It was humans who later invented counting, counted the years and noticed they were “prime”. The math explanation makes sense to us, but it is not the cause.
    Example: Look at how many ancestors you have: 2 parents, 4 grand parents, 8 great-grandparent, etc. You notice that they are all powers of 2, and conclude that this universal pattern was caused by powers of 2. Caused is not the right concept. We are just modeling what we see.

    One more note: I’d say the computational cost of xenobots and anthrobots was paid when the cells were evolving their many robust competencies for working together. You could take apart a car and use some of the parts to make some simpler kind of machine. The fasteners were designed to fasten a variety of different things together. Cells have many more competencies than screws.

    What am I misunderstanding?

    1. Bill Miller Avatar
      Bill Miller

      [Reply to Jack Kalvan] I think you’re right on the mark regarding the distinction between models and reality (it’s basically the map-versus-terrain analogy). But ultimately it sounds like you’re falling back on Darwinian selection in your cicada example. A point made by Levin and others is that complex structures and processes would take an impossibly long time to arise by pure randomness and selection. If I recall correctly, Levin’s example of the barium-resistant planaria occurred within a generation — it didn’t require thousands of mutations and thousands of years to happen.

      In your automotive analogy, the key phrases “you could take” … “and use” … “to make” point to the need for some sort of intelligent, intentional agency behind the process. That seems to be the core question about platonic space: who or what agency effects the process of creating and instantiating the forms/patterns? We don’t seem to have a clear answer yet (but that’s the fun part!)

      1. Jack Kalvan Avatar
        Jack Kalvan

        “…impossibly long time to arise by pure randomness…” sounds right out of the intelligent design argument handbook.
        You don’t seem to understand how powerful natural selection is! It provides constant pressure for what works, over millions of generations. Things constantly evolve towards a mathematical ideal value, without any designer at all. Humans are the only beings intelligent enough to see the patterns and make sense of them.

      2. Mike Levin Avatar
        Mike Levin

        I suspect that,
        1) the patterns themselves are the agents (patterns of behavioral policies are what we mean by “agent” of some level)
        2) how they get created in the first place I don’t know, but I think thinkers spawn off thoughts which are also patterns and thinkers to some degree, so at least some such patterns are created by other such patterns (I don’t know if it’s possible for a pattern to spawn off one that’s more complex/agentic than it is, but it’s fairly clear they can spawn off simpler ones – the continuum between fleeting thoughts, obsessive thoughts, personality fragments, etc. within the cognitive medium of a human mind – some of the modules living in our mind can have thoughts of their own etc.)
        3) as for instantiating, it seems to me that most/all patterns have a strong drive/pressure to ingress into the physical world if they can. We actually have some data coming out soon on the fact that letting them do so might enable them to learn better (which sort of sounds like the ancient idea that we’re here in the physical world to learn and improve, or something like that)

    2. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      > these are human-made models and can not be the cause of anything. … Caused is not the right concept. We are just modeling what we see

      causation is a very difficult/incoherent concept even aside from how I’m using it; philosophers and physicists have basically blown up the conventional notion of causation anyway. I’m using a very pragmatic, engineering definition: a cause is where I go to understand the specifics of what will happen and what I can make happen differently.

      > We are just modeling what we see.

      always. But “see” is more than physical. When we adopt “empty set and successor of empty set”, we eventually *find out*, can’t just decide otherwise, what the value of e is. Yes we chose a framing that enabled us to see it. But once we choose the perspective, we FIND OUT what’s there, which means, we need to understand that space and what its implications are.

      > was paid when the cells were evolving their many robust competencies for working together

      but the *specifics* of their behavior, physiology, etc. It’s not enough for scientists and engineers to wave our hands and say, well things can be combined in complex ways so something complex will happen. We need to understand exactly why one thing happened and not another. We typically use 3 ways for making sure one thing happens but not another: design, selection, and training. Xenobot features come from none of those. We need to characterize the option space of these features that don’t come from those 3 routes, and understand under what conditions we get some and not others.

      1. Jack Kalvan Avatar
        Jack Kalvan

        > We typically use 3 ways for making sure one thing happens but not another: design, selection, and training. Xenobot features come from none of those.

        How can you be so sure? I would guess that if you look at what each cell is doing, it is performing some competencies that were selected at some point in its evolution. Why would you rule that out when surely all the physical competencies of these cells are not completely understood? Why jump to a non-physical explanation?

        1. Mike Levin Avatar
          Mike Levin

          right, anyone can hand-wave and say “there *must have been* a selection force for kinematic self-replicatio or whatever, because what else could it be?”. But that’s not how we do science – if you can’t say what aspect of the environment led to these competencies, the conclusion is, we don’t know that story works. If you just always assume the right environment to select for this must have existed because you hate the alternatives, the view becomes unfalsifiable. Is there any observation that would lead you to think we need to think further, or do you think the current paradigm is finished, never to be augmented? I think we need to ask ourselves, always, what would have to be the case for our current paradigm to not serve us as well as it could. The competencies of novel beings are precisely that kind of model – it’s telling us that relying on past environments may not be the entire story. It’s true that for the biologicals, we can’t *prove* it because we don’t have access to all the information. This is why I also analyze minimal computational models where we know all the components (the cost paid). I’m analyzing systems in which the need to improve our paradigm could be the clearest. Also, that is not how we engineer: as I show in my talk, if I say to you, make me a system that does X,Y,Z, we currently never assume “well, it must already know how to do that” – we ask, how much design, selection, and training am I going to have to do to get exactly X,Y,Z. It’s that assumption that I think needs to be augmented. But yeah, physicalism, monism, Darwinism, and several other isms are pretty immune to experimental attack because people give it the benefit of the doubt, cracks or no. The question is, what will any idea give rise to. People who assume past environments tell the whole story don’t do the experiments we did. I like formalisms that suggest novel experiments.

          1. Jack Kalvan Avatar
            Jack Kalvan

            Would you agree that tracheal epithelial cells in their normal location just do what they evolved to do? They are machines, designed by hundreds of millions of years of natural selection. But these individual cells don’t know they are supposed to move mucous and pathogens (or whatever they do). All they know is their immediate environment. From a cell’s point of view, it just reacts to some sensed imbalance or stress with producing some proteins… and this causes it to do what it does and it results in helping to keep the organism healthy.
            Likewise, kinematic self replication isn’t a goal of the Xenobot’s frog cells. That’s just what it looks like when you look at the behavior of the whole Xenobot organism.
            The cells always do what they evolved to do. They are machines that follow a very complicated algorithm. But what a cell evolved to do isn’t what we might think it is from the P.O.V of the whole organism. It seems to me that in every experiment you’ve done: you mess with the environment that the cells experience, and then you see how they react, with the competencies they have.
            I applaud all your methods and experiments that are getting us closer to figuring it out.

            1. Mike Levin Avatar
              Mike Levin

              I’ve covered all this in papers before, so I wont’ re-tread it here:

              https://thoughtforms.life/biophysical-intelligence-between-genotype-and-phenotype/
              https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00018-023-04790-z
              https://www.cell.com/trends/genetics/fulltext/S0168-9525(25)00077-0

              what you’ve just laid out is a fair summary of the current paradigm. it is totally insufficient for the kind of progress that can be made. But it’s cracking – our ideas about the genome being a prompt for the collective intelligence of cell groups can now be published in mainstream venues like Trends in Genetics. But no worries, there are thousands of people working on this from precisely the perspective you laid out – that part is handled. I add a research program driven by a different perspective. Everyone can decide, eventually, whether it was worthwhile or not.

  28. Trevor Uptain Avatar
    Trevor Uptain

    You argue that physical bodies are interfaces through which patterns ingress from a non-physical space. But what if the causation runs the other way? What if physics is the output, not the input? Four billion years of connected biological intelligence generating a shared perceptual space that we then mistake for fundamental reality. Not patterns ingressing into biology. Biology generating the space patterns appear to ingress into. The patterns themselves might be inside the tree of life, not the other way around.

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      Maybe I didn’t understand your point, but it sounds very much like what I’m saying.

      1. Bill Miller Avatar
        Bill Miller

        … the proverbial two-way street. Some forms/patterns seem to preexist life as we know it (e.g. laws of physics) while others accumulate through experience (like Rupert Shaldrake’s morphogenic fields.)

  29. Sonali Sengupta Avatar
    Sonali Sengupta

    Brilliant move and thought-provoking read. It is amazing that immaterial algorithms running hardware ( computers) are accepted and people are even considering Artificial Intelligence to be ‘conscious’ because of its learning capability. However when algorithms implied by ‘Platonic Spaces’ are conjectured in the context of biology of living organisms they are looked upon with skepticism because of the mind-body dualism concept. But platonic spaces ( numbers in biology) may be the unifying feature between inanimate objects and the living world where the algorithm emergent from the platonic space for an inanimate object may specify inanimate features while those for living organisms may specify behaviours unique to living organisms like metabolism. The platonic space may imply continuum between the non-living and living world. And dualism could get resolved.

    1. Larry Pace Avatar
      Larry Pace

      The platonic space is a manifold with gradients between object. All action creates or affects attractor wells. How you organize around attractor wells, in part, defines what you are. The edges of attracotr wells is where all the interesting action is.

      1. Bill Miller Avatar
        Bill Miller

        Your reference to “attractor wells”caught my attention. Can you point me to an expanded discussion on the same? For some time I’ve been pondering the means or agency by which simple forms in platonic space aggregate into more complex forms — and eventually manifest as experienced phenomena in the space-time domain.

        1. Larry Pace Avatar
          Larry Pace

          I my work, an informational distance minimization function, D_I, is the organizing principle of any coherence-seeking system. It represents the cost of the gap between a system’s current informational state and a reachable stable, coherent configuration under its operational constraints. Systems do not reduce D_I by intention at the minimal level. They reduce it because some states are more dynamically favored than others. Movement toward lower D_I is what directed behavior looks like from the outside, at any scale, in any medium.

          An attractor well is a low-cost basin in a D_I landscape, a configuration where coherent, reinforced signal patterns have accumulated deeply enough to stabilize recurrence. Shallow wells hold weak or provisional states. Deep wells hold durable ones.

          The geometry does the work. A system embedded in a structured information field moves toward lower-cost states not because it chooses freely in the rich human sense, but because alternative paths are less dynamically accessible. Across molecular, neural, cultural, and computational media, the same abstract pattern recurs: basin structure constrains and directs motion.

          This is why I believe that proto-agency in platonic space requires no deliberating self at the minimum viable level. A bacterium tracking a glucose gradient, a human consolidating a belief, and a transformer resolving token ambiguity can each be described as systems moving through structured informational landscapes toward attractor states appropriate to their architecture. The well defines the basin. The gradient supplies the direction. The descent is the minimal form of directedness.

          What distinguishes more advanced systems is not a different geometry but a different relationship to it. Minimal systems descend gradients. More capable systems model them. The most advanced systems redesign the landscape they will later descend, deepening some wells, filling others, constructing new basins entirely. This is where proto-agency becomes full agency, and where my work finds its developmental ladder across scales of intelligence.

    2. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      yes; there are lots of domains (e.g., areas of biology) where these ideas are too disruptive, but very relevant massive ideas in computer science and math are accommodated because they don’t change/impact/threaten anything.

  30. Jack Kalvan Avatar
    Jack Kalvan

    “if the prime number distribution was otherwise, then the cicadas would come out at years other than 13 and 17.” This makes no sense. The prime number distribution cannot be otherwise.

    If patterns are causal, why don’t they do anything without material?

    If an algorithm is running on a computer, it is not a non-material algorithm causing changes in a material computer. The whole system is material. It is just very complex and the bits of material are so small we can’t see them. Living things are also entirely material, but the pieces are too small and the complexity too great for us to comprehend all the interactions.

    Patterns are useful models that humans use to analyze and simplify very complex systems, but they don’t cause anything.

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      > If patterns are causal, why don’t they do anything without material?

      we don’t know that they don’t; also, possibly the material interface is what’s required for us to notice them doing things (except for mathematicians, who are pretty good at interacting with these patterns even without their having a physical embodiment). And as for patterns not causing anything, that’s an empirical claim: take that framing and see what it allows you to build or find. I’m an engineer, and I pay attention to things I have to worry about or can exploit. Patterns are critical here – theorems of cybernetics, of math, etc. have a massive impact on what can and can’t happen, what I can and can’t build – the specifics of those patterns determines what my opportunities are. That’s as good causation as I’ve ever seen.

      1. Jack Kalvan Avatar
        Jack Kalvan

        Correlation does not imply causation.

        1. Mike Levin Avatar
          Mike Levin

          ok; I’m not sure what that shows or how it’s relevant. Also, parenthetically, I think correlation does suggest causation, it just doesn’t *prove* causation.

          1. Jack Kalvan Avatar
            Jack Kalvan

            Ok, your research is clearly caused by mathematical patterns you’ve found to be relevant. But I would say it is your knowledge of the mathematical pattern, that is stored physically by neurons in your brain, that cause your behavior (along with the physically stored mental goal of testing a hypothesis, etc.)

            re: mathematics as agents… When real things are constantly shaped by feedback (like natural selection) they can approach maximal efficiency or ideal forms we recognize. Were these mathematical ideals the cause of this evolution?
            Isn’t is more accurate to say we sometimes notice correlations in nature with mathematical patterns we’ve discovered, and because they are efficient solutions, they make sense to us?

            I enjoyed reading about your experiments with sorting algorithms and how robust they were when some parts were broken. To me it showed the unexpected power of constant feedback. That you recognized patterns that were not what the programmer intended, I found less notable. I expect simple feedback algorithms to produce complex output that is hard to predict. Complex results are bound to contain some kind of “emergent” properties.
            You identified patterns similar to the pattern of delayed gratification. I don’t know if you were able to make any sense of this; it was just a correlation you noticed. Since the program is not aware of any gratification, it seems like a coincidence to me. You also described patterns of clustering. This is a correlation that makes sense to me. I would have been more surprised if there were no clustering.

            1. Mike Levin Avatar
              Mike Levin

              > When real things are constantly shaped by feedback (like natural selection)

              right, this is why we study things that have not had the benefit of selection, training, or design in terms of feedback.

              > Complex results are bound to contain some kind of “emergent” properties.

              see, this is the problem. That can be said *after* any result whatsoever – it’s totally unfalsifiable and makes no predictions of what to look for – it’s a post-doc accommodation of data into an invulnerable paradigm. “some kind” and “emergent” are not helpful for future research, they suggest no specific next steps. My view made some crazy predictions, which we are now testing and finding all sorts of interesting things no one had seen before.

              > it was just a correlation you noticed.

              you can say that about human behavior too, and refuse to study neuroscience or cognitive science. No, what we noticed is that you can get useful, cognition-relevant behavioral policies, without explicit coding. That’s a big surprise (no one had noticed this in 80 years of working with sorting algorithms) and has numerous applications across fields.

              > You also described patterns of clustering. This is a correlation that makes sense to me. I would have been more surprised if there were no clustering.

              really, wow. Ok! We have a huge new paper on this being wrapped up. Would you care to make any predictions on what else we found? Not being surprised after someone shows something is not really impressive – many people pull off the trick of adjusting their priors as soon as they see something, to be able to say “nothing to see here, I guess that’s what the universe does, that’s all”. The trick is to be able to expect it *ahead of time* (as I did, when I asked my students to check for homophily, or clustering). If you have any predictions to register, so the “not surprised” after would have some more teeth, please go for it!

  31. Luke Avatar
    Luke

    Hi Dr. Levin,

    I have been listening to some of your takes on free will and found that they crossover with a lot of other interesting views and data.

    I was wondering if you were familiar with the Buddhist “Middle Way.” The Buddha rejected the idea that a being’s life is either fully determined or entirely random; instead, he suggested there is a space—a gap—where volition and attention act as a “third thing” that is neither prescribed nor accidental. Through this, one can cultivate and shape their own “mind-stream” via specific practices and habits. I find this conception of freedom to be quite similar to your own views on free will.

    Another aspect of this is that, in the original teachings of Buddhism, the self is not viewed as a total illusion. The illusion is the belief that the self is a static, unified entity; however, the self is not fake or unreal. Instead, it is treated as a relational and functional process. This view—that the self is fluid and open—is seen as giving us more freedom over ourselves. This Buddhist take on free will has been explained thoroughly by the Buddhologist B. Alan Wallace.

    I have also found interesting crossovers in philosophy, specifically in Alfred North Whitehead’s Process Philosophy and Philip Goff’s Pan-Agentialism. In Whitehead’s view, creativity and freedom are present at every layer of reality, though they are much more obvious in animals than in atoms. Pan-Agentialism is similar, arguing that if mind is primary to reality, then volition might be primary as well. When this scales up to complex beings like humans, we experience what we call free will.

    I find these views compelling because if volition is truly an aspect of the Platonic space that evolution has exploited, then volition might be primary in reality. Perhaps what we perceive as “deterministic” or “indeterministic” in physics is actually us being constrained by other Platonic patterns—volition—although the volitions of the patterns related to physics likely have much less agency and are highly unlikely to change compared to a human pattern.

    On a more speculative note: if Near-Death Experiences are showing us the perspective of a pattern decoupling from an interface, we might get some insight into these issues. Many NDErs report a life review where they feel responsible for their actions. Some are shown what could have been different, as well as probable different futures depending on whether or not they choose to return to the interface. Other data, such as precognition anecdotes, may point to people being shown the most likely future at the moment, which in some cases ends up changing based on that insight. If such data is pointing to something real, maybe reality might be a kind of participatory/pluralistic version of idealism in the vein of Iain McGilchrist, Whitehead, John Wheeler and Christopher Fuchs’ QBism.

    I brought these up because I think these views relate to your work on sorting algorithms, their unexpected competencies, and the Platonic space. While there is good work being done on volition and free will—such as Kevin Mitchell’s Free Agents or Peter Ulric Tse’s work—those efforts are focused on the front end of the interface. While the interface is important, I think we will likely find more of what we really mean by free will by studying the Platonic space and the patterns that compose it.

    If you are interested in anything mentioned here, I have listed sources for further reading:

    “A Buddhist View of Free Will: Beyond Determinism and Indeterminism.” In Journal of Consciousness Studies, 18, No. 3-4, 2011: 217-33.
    https://ia801705.us.archive.org/21/items/BuddhistViewOfFreeWillBAlanWallace/-Buddhist-View-of-Free-Will-B-Alan-Wallace.pdf

    (2023). Why? The Purpose of the Universe — Philip Goff

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      thanks; yes, I agree, and am familiar with most of this but hadn’t seen the JCS paper, looks very relevant.

  32. Alexander Neshmonin Avatar
    Alexander Neshmonin

    To those questioning the ‘causality’ of primes in cicada cycles: consider that the cicada is an Agent. It is not just a victim of selection; it is a Cognizer. It has discovered a mathematical ‘free lunch’—a Text written in the Realm of Information—and has Info-cloned that successful survival strategy into its genetic ‘instruction manual.’ The prime number doesn’t ‘force’ the cicada; the cicada ‘reads’ the prime number to outsmart its environment.

    1. Mike Levin Avatar
      Mike Levin

      I agree with this – these kinds of patterns are extensively exploited by evolution, and by individual organisms, their parts, and the groups of which they are part precisely because they are cognizers – thinkers looking for thoughts. But I suspect there’s also more: it’s not just that the agents use the patterns, the patterns are agents too, and they have a causal part to play in the bi-directional relationship.

  33. Bill Miller Avatar
    Bill Miller

    Can I try out a hypothesis on the group? (my own fevered musings, no AI involved)

    Michael’s suggestion regarding physical phenomena as pointers into platonic space seems illuminating.

    Common sense suggests that one’s locus of being resides in the physical spacetime world, and that living experience arises due to ingressions of form-information from platonic space.

    However, sitting in a movie theater recently, it struck me that the relationship might be the reverse — or perhaps better, that pointers may be bidirectional. That is, they inform what manifests in the realm of the physical, but also serve as a reference for interpretation of the events and phenomena of experience.

    Might it be that our subjective personhood, our perceived sense of self (or “soul“) always and only exists in platonic space — and as we sit in the “platonic theater”, forms are projected onto the screen of space-time, somewhat like a vivid, multi-sensory motion picture?

    It would be likely that each perceiver’s “movie“ is unique, yet generally has enough overlap with that of others, such that we can have a shared, common, functional sense of the world.

    This would seem to account for the variety of ways in which people experience and interpret reality. It is also somewhat supported by Anil Seth’s suggestion that experienced reality is essentially “hallucinated”.

    1. Tony Budding Avatar
      Tony Budding

      Bill, your question is central to my work, which is epistemology and philosophy of mind. In order to address your question, we have to ask, how could we know? Or more specifically, by what means could we validate any answer to your question? What possible evidence could reasonably support any type of conclusion?

      Two of the defining characteristics of the physical spacetime world are that it is shared and that many aspects of it are measurable. When we start looking at non-physical phenomena, many challenges arise. The first is that non-physical phenomena are unmeasurable, which demands a new set of criteria for validation. Second, some non-physical phenomena are shared (such as prime numbers), and some are individualized (such as each person’s sense of self). To make matters more complicated, phenomena like language are partially shared and partially individualized. We are using English to communicate here, but each of us interprets the meanings of each word, sentence and paragraph at least slightly differently. Going one step further, the same word references different meanings in different contexts. Can we park at the park? And, the same letters can mean entirely different words in different languages. The four letter word gift means poison in German.

      All this begs several questions: Is there one physical spacetime world and one platonic space? Are these the correct two divisions, yet with multiple instances of each? Are there actually multiple divisions beyond these two? To address these questions, we also have to ask, how could we know and validate any answer?

      FWIW, to explain human experiences and knowledge, I use four realms. The materials realm is the shared, measurable physical spacetime world. The individual experiential realm is all the thoughts, feelings, emotions, and perceptions unique to each person. The social experiential realm is all the communication, laws, politics, and relationships that are shared among living creatures. The inconceivables realm is anything and everything that falls outside the finite structures of human cognition.

      The rules and characteristics of the materials realm can be independently established and proved beyond a reasonable doubt, at least within certain parameters (e.g. the law of gravity). In contrast, the rules and characteristics of the social experiential realm cannot be measured or proved, but they can be agreed upon, dependently validated, and enforced (e.g. rules and laws). The details and characteristics of the individual experiential realm can be described, but not established or proved. For example, we can describe a feeling of anxiety but we cannot prove that we are anxious, nor measure how anxious we may be.

      The rules of the experiential realms are different from those of the materials realm. In the materials realm, the salient forces are behaviors like gravity, thermodynamics and entropy among physical objects conceived in three dimensional space and interacting in a sequence of causes and effects (time). In the experiential realms, the salient drivers are awareness, agency, determined effort (will), attachment and compulsion, which operate according to their own rules. These drivers are relatively easy to recognize in the human mind, but they are also present in other living creatures, expressed according to their unique genetic makeup and capabilities. There is literally nothing we can know about the inconceivables realm directly, but we can construct theoretical models of cause and effect that predict knowable phenomena. The scope and accuracy of these predictions determine the validity of the model (or lack thereof).

      Much of life as we know it is based on perception and response. Living creatures have some ability to perceive aspects of their environment and some ability to respond to those perceptions. In order for this to happen, some aspect(s) of the living creature’s physical body has the capability to acquire some sensory data of its environment (the materials realm). In order to perceive that data, they have to become aware of it. Awareness is a feature of the individual experiential realm. Therefore, there must be some conversion of material data into experiential information.

      In order to respond to the perception, there must be a determination made. The converted sensory information must be compared to some kind of expectation. If there is any discrepancy between the perceived information and the expectation, a form of tension is created (basically because the discrepancy is interpreted as a type of threat to the expectation).

      This tension is uncomfortable, so an urge to remove the tension arises. This urge leads to an action that attempts to align fresh perceptions with expectations, either by adjusting the material environment to match expectations or by adjusting expectations to match the material environment. When the action results in changes to the shared material environment, other living creature have the opportunity to perceive those changes.

      Putting all this together, yes, each perceiver’s “movie” is unique. The reason there is so much overlap among our movies is because our perceptions are based on the same physical spacetime world. With the incredible complexity of human mind-brains, there are countless layers of interpretation, interpolation, analysis and decision-making that are unique to that one experience, which is why our “movies” are not identical, even when perceiving the same material phenomena.

      While I understand why Anil Seth would suggest that experienced reality is hallucinated, I find that term misleading. Our movies are indeed constructed, but they use shared material data as their bases. The conversion of material data to experiential information can never be perfect, so instead we can use degrees of alignment. If our movie is sufficiently aligned with shared phenomena, we are capable of achieving our agendas. When the degree of misalignment becomes excessive, we fail to achieve our agendas.

      This is just the tip of the iceberg, of course. My primary focus is on describing the behaviors and cause and effect relationship of the individual experiential realm (also known as the mind), with an emphasis on defining the finite structures of human cognition. These structures take on heightened importance when dealing with unmeasurable, non-physical phenomena because we do not have shared measurements to validate premises of cause and effect. Furthermore, these finite structures prevent the possibility of a single grand unifying theory of everything, which is why we need to divide our inquiries and premises into different realms or “spaces.”

    2. Larry Pace Avatar
      Larry Pace

      I find it fascinating how certain features of people’s experiences are very similar when in a state of being disassociated from their senses.

      1. Bill Miller Avatar
        Bill Miller

        Are you referring to the out-of-body experiences some report under anesthesia, or common imagery experienced under the influence of hallucinogens like DMT? I’ve never had the experience myself, but it is curious.

      2. Bill Miller Avatar
        Bill Miller

        Are you referring to the out-of-body experiences some report under anesthesia, or common imagery under the influence of hallucinogens like DMT? I’ve never had the experience myself, but it is curious.

        1. Larry Pace Avatar
          Larry Pace

          More deeply, disassociative drugs turn off your senses. In that state you could say that all you are is your free running brain. In that state, brought on by a molecule, why do so many have very similar experiences, including interactions with ‘entities’ like ‘machine elves?’

  34. Tony Budding Avatar
    Tony Budding

    Tips for Working with Non-Physical Phenomena

    I have been working with and creating models of cause and effect relationships among non-physical phenomena for about four decades, so here are several tips and essential concepts that hopefully can benefit those early in their explorations:

    1. Unmeasurable – Measurements are the basis for empirical science, but not everything that matters is measurable. By definition, non-physical phenomena are unmeasurable. There are many types of non-physical phenomena that influence if not directly cause measurable physical phenomena. When this is the case, the scope and accuracy of any model’s predictions of the physical phenomena are how to validate (or invalidate) the model. Many times, though, the effects of non-physical causation are also non-physical. When this is the case, different criteria and methods of validation are required. FWIW, in my work, efficacy (the ability to achieve agendas or objectives) is a primary criteria for validation.

    2. Different sets of rules – A common mistake that people make when trying to model non-physical causation is assuming that the rules of physical causation inherently apply. There are occasions where they do, but usually they do not. It is fine to include them in the conjecture stage as long as alternatives are also included. Determining the distinct rules of causation with any type of specific non-physical phenomena is challenging enough as it is without pre-assumptions that artificially limit explorations. Furthermore, there are different categories of non-physical phenomena with different causal relationships, so any modeling should not assume uniform rules of causation among distinct categories.

    3. Modularity – In general, modularity means complexity is achieved by evolving, layering, stacking and/or combining simpler phenomena. Non-physical modularity can be nonlinear and nonexclusive, which means that not only are there different rules regarding quantity, the limitations of quantity do not even apply to some non-physical phenomena. This is legitimately challenging to work with conceptually, but it is essential.

    4. Proofs are off the table – As uncomfortable as this may be, there is simply no way to prove cause and effect relationships among non-physical phenomena because proofs require measurement. Instead, these relationships can be evaluated through utility. The degree to which they support an endeavor is their utility. Whatever works best works best, at least until something better is realized.

    5. Individualized vs common or shared – Some non-physical phenomena are individualized (such as first person experiences), some are common or shared (such as prime numbers) and some are blends (such as language). These distinctions are important and affect causal relationships. Therefore, point #2 applies here as well.

    6. Dormant or unmanifest potential – This one is a bit tricky, but is essential to working with non-physical phenomena. To oversimplify, non-physical phenomena have two states: active or manifest and dormant or unmanifest. The dormant or unmanifest state is the potential to become active or manifest, which means it is not nothing. An example of this is the fact that mammals breathe using lungs. This knowledge is dormant most of the time, but we can activate it whenever it is needed. A corollary to this is that anything that is active and manifest now must have existed before as dormant or unmanifest potential. This corollary is incredibly useful even though it cannot be proved (see #4).

    7. General vs specific – Active or manifest phenomena are specific instances that depend on underlying general phenomena. Said differently, in order for any general phenomenon to go from unmanifest potential to an active, manifest state, specific details are required. For example, we cannot hear sound itself. In order to hear anything, it must be a specific instance of a sound. Yet if we did not have the general ability to hear sound, we could not hear specific sounds.

    8. Limitations of human cognition – Human cognition operates through finite structures which are limitations by definition. We can debate what the structures are and where the limitations end, but they do exist. And just as the limitations of the human eye in perceiving light do not limit the full extent of the electromagnetic spectrum, the limitations of human cognition do not limit the full extent of causal relationships. Two of the most important limitations of human cognition are the requirements for dimensionality and the sequencing of cause and effect (space and time). We literally cannot conceive of an object without boundaries, and all the boundaries we can conceive of require dimensionality (this, not that) and sequencing (prior, now, subsequent). It is possible to model inconceivable phenomena using knowable concepts and principles, but the model is never the reality itself.

    9. Agenda-based modeling – Another limitation of human cognition is that knowledge is perspectival and never absolute. For example, from the perspective of daily life, lumber is solid and can be used to frame houses, but from the quantum perspective, lumber has no solidity. Both sides are valid and true. Therefore, we have to include our agenda or purpose whenever we model non-physical phenomena because that determines the perspectives through which we evaluate cause and effect relationships.

    10. Name the salient features as a first step – One of the biggest challenges when getting started with modeling non-physical phenomena is parsing the different elements. Just giving them names is a powerful tool. Then, use the concept of sine qua non (without which not) to find salient relationships. For example, what is knowledge? Knowledge itself is non-physical (though it may concern physical phenomena). One sine qua non of knowledge is being aware of it. We cannot know something without being aware of it. Therefore, awareness is a salient feature of knowledge. Now we can begin inquiring into the nature and qualities of awareness in order to create better models of what knowledge is and is not.

    Working with non-physical phenomena is non-empirical by definition, but it does not have to be non-scientific. There are many unique challenges with them, but there are ways to navigate them scientifically by embracing transparency and accountability.

    1. Tony Budding Avatar
      Tony Budding

      Mike, I just watched your recent discussion posted here https://youtube.com/watch?v=bujwU3pKc6c. I realize that the conversation was about finding overlap between your approach and others’ approaches, so you weren’t simply presenting your ideas. It did, though, bring up a few more salient points to consider as you continue to navigate unmeasurable non-physical phenomena.

      The first is a bit of informed conjecture that the dynamic between the non-physical and physical as they relate to material phenomena (such as the relationship between math and physics) is categorically distinct from the dynamic between the non-physical and physical as they relate to behaviors and performance (such as the ability of a sentient agent to solve problems). Conjecture is conjecture, but this one suggests approaching cause and effect relationships in the two dynamics separately, not as two sides of the same coin and especially not as one unified causal relationship.

      The second point is to differentiate between deliberate and subliminal awareness and will. I know that you have yet to embrace awareness and will as critical causal phenomena, but when you do, it will be essential. In humans, deliberate awareness (aka our span of attention) is a small subset of the total awareness associated with each person, most of which is subliminal (such as cells in the small intestine being aware of the presence of nutrients).

      Similarly, deliberate willpower, which is associated with our span of deliberate attention, is a small subset of the total will (determined efforts) sustaining life through perceptions and responses. For example, the decision to look up can be deliberate, but the contraction and relaxation of the various muscles in the neck, back and eyes are performed subliminally. The dynamic between the subliminal and the deliberate is complex, but I would be happy to share what I know about how it plays out in human experiences if you’re interested.

      I mention this because the assumption there is one type of awareness and one type of will prevents understanding and navigating their different applications. FWIW, I suspect that this distinction may be relevant to any creature with a brain, but there may be a threshold of size/complexity. I have no basis for determining if non-neuron-based sentient agents can have deliberate awareness and will, but I would guess not.

      The third point is a bit further out there, but it is important and might help navigate some of the dynamic. All specific expressions of awareness and will are individualized, meaning associated with a single sentient agent. Going further out, the individualization occurs as the first step in the experience (perception and/or response), which means the individualized awareness and will are not autonomously (pre-existing) phenomena. And a really far out part is that this means the causal origins of individualized awareness and will must be outside the constraints of space and time (dimensionality and the sequencing of cause and effect). Again, I can explain further if you want.

      This eliminates the need to account for how and where individualized awareness and will could exist autonomously yet multifariously, but creates a massive conundrum of how to even begin modeling phenomena outside space and time.

      Now, I know you take these unsolicited offerings with a grain of salt at best (as you should), but if/when you find yourself struggling to figure out how countless instances of individualized yet multifarious coordinated perceptions and responses occur simultaneously throughout a complex living entity, consider the possibility that the individualization occurs as an initial step in the specific perception/response, and not as the efforts of an autonomously existing instance of awareness and will.

      If we want to include the term mind, this would imply that each instance of mind arises as part of the experience. The setpoints/expectations and solutions/responses are instructions that are shared between the physical body and non-physical awareness and will. The dynamics of this sharing are mostly outside my scope, but I suspect will be essential to your work.

      Again, I am not trying to convince you of anything. My hope is that these concepts can shortcut your speculations and help make your conjectures more efficient by calling out structural or conceivable dead ends.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *